The spin-off theory in the sui generis right: distinguishing between the creation and obtaining of data

Read full text Summarise with VIRAT
Authors: Vladyslav Vyshnevskyi
Cited by: 0
References: 7

Summary

No summary yet. VIRAT can read this paper and write a plain-language summary of its aim, methods, key findings and limitations.

Summarise with VIRAT Free to try with your Science Catalogs account.

Abstract

The article examines the fundamental legal distinction between the processes of creating and obtaining data in the context of granting sui generis protection to databases. The relevance of the topic stems from the growing tension between Directive 96/9/EC and contemporary data-driven economic realities. Originally designed for static databases, the Directive now operates in an environment characterised by dynamic data sets, including sports statistics and Internet of Things (IoT) sensor data. This technological shift has created a legal paradox whereby commercially valuable datasets fall outside the scope of protection due to their qualification as «spin-off» by-products of primary economic activities. The study aims to define the substantive legal boundaries of the sui generis right by analysing the evolution of the spin-off theory and by formulating practical criteria for assessing substantial investment under national law. Methodologically, the research employs doctrinal and comparative legal methods in combination with the economic analysis of law (in particular, the «sole source» theory and the concept of sunk costs). It demonstrates that the creation/obtaining dichotomy functions as an inherent anti-monopolisation safeguard. The article traces the evolution of judicial doctrine from the exclusion of sports event data to the consistent denial of protection for operational business data, as well as scientific and technical data. Particular emphasis is placed on recent jurisprudence confirming that investments in generating new technical know-how relating to compatibility constitute acts of creation rather than verification. The scientific novelty lies in the development of a conceptual three-part Data Origin Test for interpreting Article 21 of the Law of Ukraine «On Copyright and Related Rights». This sequential assessment involves: (1) determining whether the data pre-existed in objective reality; (2) analysing the purpose of the investment to identify spin-off products; and (3) distinguishing between the verification of objective truth and the verification of recording accuracy. This approach enables a clear distinction between unprotected costs of data creation and protected substantial investments in obtaining, verifying, or presenting the contents of a database, thereby ensuring a proper balance of interests within the data economy.

Fields of Study & Subjects

Intellectual Property Law Intellectual Property Rights and Media Digitalization Law and Regulation

Publication details

Journal / source
Uzhhorod National University Herald Series Law
Volume
1
Issue
93
Pages
380–389
Publication date
19 March 2026
Language
EN