The quality of judicial decisions in the context of European standards (using the example of commercial litigation)

Read full text Summarise with VIRAT
Authors: V.V. Reznikova, Оксана Зіновіївна Хотинська-Нор, Yurii D. PRYTYKA
Cited by: 0

Summary

No summary yet. VIRAT can read this paper and write a plain-language summary of its aim, methods, key findings and limitations.

Summarise with VIRAT Free to try with your Science Catalogs account.

Abstract

The article highlights the issue of the quality of judicial decisions as an integral indicator of the quality and efficiency of justice in the state from the perspective of European standards in the field of commercial litigation. The research was based on key documents in this area from various bodies of the Council of Europe: the European Commission for the Efficiency of Justice, the Consultative Council of European Judges and the European Court of Human Rights, which have long paid significant attention to the issue of the quality of judicial decisions. It is noted that the quality of judicial decisions is an integral, multidimensional characteristic of a judicial act, reflecting the degree of its compliance with legal, logical, procedural, ethical and communicative standards of justice. The quality of judicial decisions ensures the effective implementation of the functions of the judiciary and guarantees compliance with the principles of the rule of law, justice, and legal certainty. The multidimensionality of the studied category lies in the presence of several interrelated aspects: normative, rational, procedural, communicative, social, functional, and axiological. In the science of procedural law, the concept of the quality of a judicial decision acquires systemic significance within the concept of effective justice, which combines formal procedural guarantees and substantive validity. The quality of a judicial decision is interdependent with the efficiency of commercial litigation: quality is the substantive core of efficiency, ensuring legality, predictability and trust; efficiency is an organizational prerequisite for quality, guaranteeing the proper conditions for a well-founded, fair judicial decision. A generalization of the positions of various European institutions led to the conclusion that European standards encourage us to consider and evaluate the quality of judicial decisions through the prism of such elements as: clarity and reasoning; legal accuracy; fair hearing and responsiveness; coherence and consistency; enforceability. However, Ukraine’s European integration in modern conditions involves not only a formal approximation to the standards formed by the institutions mentioned in this publication, but also a systemic transformation of justice in terms of accessibility, predictability, motivation, and enforceability of judicial acts.

Fields of Study & Subjects

Legal processes and jurisprudence Education Law and Society European and International Law Studies

Publication details

Journal / source
Uzhhorod National University Herald Series Law
Volume
2
Issue
93
Pages
95–101
Publication date
24 March 2026
Language
EN