Administrative liability for negligent destruction or damage to military property (Article 172-12 of the Code of Ukraine on Administrative Offenses): analysis of judicial practice
Summary
No summary yet. VIRAT can read this paper and write a plain-language summary of its aim, methods, key findings and limitations.
Summarise with VIRAT Free to try with your Science Catalogs account.Abstract
The article examines administrative liability for negligent destruction or damage to military property under Article 172-12 of the Code of Ukraine on Administrative Offenses (CUAO) through the lens of judicial practice and the requirements of administrative procedure. The relevance of the topic is driven by the fact that, amid prolonged armed aggression and the heightened operational burden on the security and defence sector, preservation of military property has not only economic but also direct defence significance, while the effectiveness of liability mechanisms largely depends on procedural accuracy in documenting and proving the offense. The research aims to identify trends in court practice concerning Article 172-12 CUAO, to systematize recurring deficiencies in the documentation of administrative offense materials, and to formulate practical recommendations for law enforcement and other authorized actors. The empirical base includes 144 judicial decisions in cases under Article 172-12 CUAO for the period 01 January 2019–31 December 2025, selected from the Unified State Register of Court Decisions. The quantitative distribution of outcomes demonstrates that 41.7% of cases ended with a finding of guilt and the imposition of an administrative sanction (predominantly a fine), 17.4% resulted in release from liability due to insignificance (Article 22 CUAO), and 20.8% were terminated. A key procedural pattern is that termination most often stems from the expiration of the statutory time limits for imposing an administrative sanction (Article 38 in conjunction with Article 247(7) CUAO), indicating systemic risks related to delays in drafting and forwarding materials. Additionally, 9% of decisions involved returning materials for proper rectification, which correlates with recurring flaws in protocols and annexes: insufficient specification of time, place, and factual circumstances; overly general descriptions of the objective side of the offense without demonstrating negligence; failure to establish a causal link between conduct and damage; inadequate proof that the object qualifies as «military property» and is assigned to the responsible person; and non-compliance with the formal requirements for protocols under Article 256 CUAO. The analysis of reasoning parts of decisions shows that courts apply a structured verification of the elements of the offense and rely on the standard of relevance and admissibility of evidence (Article 251 CUAO), treating the protocol as a procedural document rather than a self-sufficient proof of guilt. The article provides process-oriented recommendations focused on improving documentation quality, ensuring time-limit control, strengthening evidence on causation and damage valuation (including the practical role of cost calculation certificates as a minimum supporting document where appropriate), and safeguarding procedural guarantees. These measures are intended to enhance the overall quality of administrative proceedings and promote greater consistency in the application of Article 172-12 CUAO.
Fields of Study & Subjects
Ukrainian Legal and Forensic Studies
Administrative Law and Governance
War
Law
and Justice
Publication details
- Journal / source
- Uzhhorod National University Herald Series Law
- Volume
- 3
- Issue
- 93
- Pages
- 213–220
- Publication date
- 23 March 2026
- Language
- EN