Evidence and substantiation in administrative proceedings: essence and significance
Summary
No summary yet. VIRAT can read this paper and write a plain-language summary of its aim, methods, key findings and limitations.
Summarise with VIRAT Free to try with your Science Catalogs account.Abstract
The article provides a comprehensive analysis of the legal nature of evidence and the process of proof in administrative judicial proceedings in Ukraine, taking into account modern challenges of public-law relations. The essence of evidence is revealed as factual data on the basis of which an administrative court establishes the existence or absence of circumstances relevant to the proper resolution of a case and verifies the legality of decisions, actions, or omissions of subjects of public authority. The authors analyze the regulatory framework governing the process of proof in accordance with the provisions of the Code of Administrative Procedure of Ukraine and summarize scholarly approaches of Ukrainian legal scholars to defining the concept, types, and sources of evidence. Particular attention is paid to the characteristics of the main stages of the proof process, namely the collection, examination, and evaluation of evidence, as well as to the role of the court in implementing the principle of official clarification of all circumstances of the case. The specifics of the burden of proof distribution in administrative proceedings are highlighted, which are обусловлені the public-law nature of disputes and the need to ensure effective protection of the rights and legitimate interests of private individuals. The range of problems arising in the practice of administrative courts during the collection, examination, and evaluation of evidence is outlined. In particular, attention is drawn to the inequality of procedural opportunities between the parties to an administrative dispute, caused by the public-authority nature of legal relations, where the respondent is predominantly a state authority or an official possessing broader informational and organizational resources. Difficulties in access to necessary information and documents by claimants are highlighted, including delays in their provision, references to the confidential or official nature of information, or the submission of incomplete data. The problem of inconsistent judicial practice regarding the admissibility, relevance, and sufficiency of evidence is also emphasized, which complicates the predictability of court decisions and negatively affects the effectiveness of the protection of the rights and legitimate interests of participants in administrative proceedings. Considerable attention is devoted to electronic evidence as a type of procedural evidence in administrative proceedings, which has become particularly relevant in the context of digitalization of the judicial system and the functioning of the “Electronic Court” system. The concept of electronic evidence is analyzed in accordance with the provisions of the Code of Administrative Procedure of Ukraine, as well as its main types and forms of existence. Special attention is paid to the specifics of submitting electronic evidence to the court, the requirements for its formalization, certification by an electronic signature, and storage in the case file. Practical difficulties related to establishing the authenticity, relevance, and admissibility of electronic evidence are highlighted, as well as problems of its examination and evaluation by the court, caused by technical aspects, the absence of unified standards, and inconsistent judicial practice. It is concluded that the proper functioning of the institution of proof is a necessary condition for ensuring the principles of the rule of law, justice, and the effectiveness of administrative judicial proceedings.
Fields of Study & Subjects
Legal processes and jurisprudence
Ukrainian Legal and Forensic Studies
Administrative Law and Governance
Publication details
- Journal / source
- Uzhhorod National University Herald Series Law
- Volume
- 3
- Issue
- 93
- Pages
- 302–310
- Publication date
- 23 March 2026
- Language
- EN