Features of judicial practice in the context of implementing state tax policy at the present stage

Read full text Summarise with VIRAT
Authors: Oksana Hinda
Cited by: 0
References: 2

Summary

No summary yet. VIRAT can read this paper and write a plain-language summary of its aim, methods, key findings and limitations.

Summarise with VIRAT Free to try with your Science Catalogs account.

Abstract

The article provides a legal analysis of tax disputes arising at the present stage. It focuses on the problem of the multiplicity of subjects of tax legal relations that relate to the public side of participants. At the same time, the article distinguishes between general and special subjects of tax legal relations. The differentiation of subjects is determined by the powers granted to one or another subject. Thus, a general subject is vested with powers exclusively to participate in relations in the field of taxation. A special subject enters into tax legal relations only under certain conditions. The paper pays special attention to the category of cases in which the Ministry of Justice or the Cabinet of Ministers of Ukraine, represented by the Ministry of Justice, is a participant. Thus, there is a tendency for tax authorities to increasingly file claims with the Ministry of Justice of Ukraine for the recovery of tax debts of penal institutions and state-owned enterprises of the State Criminal-Executive Service of Ukraine from the funds (property) of the Ministry of Justice.The author focuses on the inaccuracy of the legislator’s establishment of a military levy in the Tax Code of Ukraine, given the following. Firstly, the Tax Code of Ukraine does not define the basis for the military levy, which makes it impossible to calculate the amount to be paid, since, according to Article 29 of the Tax Code of Ukraine, the amount of tax liability is calculated by multiplying the tax base by the levy rate. Secondly, the military levy is not provided for in Articles 9-10 of the Tax Code of Ukraine, which contain a list of national and local taxes and levies. The category of disputes related to the recognition of the Resolution of the Cabinet of Ministers of Ukraine No. 178 dated 2 March 2022 ‘Certain Issues of Zero-Rated Value Added Tax during the Period of Martial Law’ as unlawful and invalid has been analysed, as this resolution stipulates that transactions involving the supply of goods and fuel and lubricants to the Armed Forces, the National Guard, etc., for the purposes of ensuring national security and defence of Ukraine, protecting the safety of the population and the interests of the state, are subject to value added tax at a zero rate. The author argues that such claims should be satisfied in view of the definition of the elements of the legal mechanism of taxation by the Cabinet of Ministers of Ukraine, which does not correspond to the provisions of tax legislation.

Fields of Study & Subjects

Ukrainian Legal and Forensic Studies Taxation and Legal Issues Economic Issues in Ukraine

Publication details

Journal / source
Uzhhorod National University Herald Series Law
Volume
3
Issue
93
Pages
64–72
Publication date
23 March 2026
Language
EN