On the issue of the moment of completion of smuggling
Summary
No summary yet. VIRAT can read this paper and write a plain-language summary of its aim, methods, key findings and limitations.
Summarise with VIRAT Free to try with your Science Catalogs account.Abstract
The article, drawing upon the achievements of criminal law doctrine, materials of judicial practice, and the provisions of regulatory (customs) legislation, clarifies the moment at which smuggling is deemed completed and, based on the analysis conducted, advances recommendations for the application of the relevant provisions of the Criminal Code of Ukraine. It is noted that the renewed attention to this long-standing, controversial issue concerning the criminal law characteristic of smuggling was prompted by its referral to the Joint Chamber of the Cassation Criminal Court of the Supreme Court. It is established that all currently effective criminal law prohibitions providing for liability for smuggling employ a uniform legislative formula in describing the objective element of the offence— namely, the movement of items across the customs border of Ukraine. Accordingly, the issue of the moment of completion of the offence should be resolved uniformly about all statutory forms of smuggling envisaged by criminal law. The article outlines and evaluates the prevailing approach in judicial practice and legal scholarship to determining the moment of completion of smuggling. This approach, among other things, is based on a grammatical interpretation of criminal legislation and defines the relevant moment with due regard to the place, direction, and method of smuggling items across Ukraine’s customs border. It is demonstrated that adherence to this traditional (differentiated) approach creates the possibility of violating the principle of justice in criminal law. At the same time, the article critically examines the assertions of certain members of the judiciary concerning an alleged dependence of the moment of completion of smuggling on the actions of customs officials. Separate consideration is given to the issue of the moment of completion of smuggling in situations where the items are detected during customs control of an international postal consignment that has arrived in Ukraine. The correctness of the corresponding legal position of the Cassation Criminal Court of the Supreme Court is called into question. It is argued that the issue of systemic inconsistency in the legislative construction of smuggling offences – which results in an unjustified differentiation of criminal liability depending on the direction of movement (import/export) of the smuggled items despite an identical degree of social harmfulness – requires resolution through amendments to the Criminal Code of Ukraine. The article outlines possible legislative changes that could address this problem.
Fields of Study & Subjects
Ukrainian Legal and Forensic Studies
Criminal Law and Policy
Crime
Illicit Activities
and Governance
Publication details
- Journal / source
- Uzhhorod National University Herald Series Law
- Volume
- 4
- Issue
- 93
- Pages
- 66–75
- Publication date
- 30 March 2026
- Language
- EN