On certain determinants affecting the legality and independence of the judiciary in Ukraine
Summary
No summary yet. VIRAT can read this paper and write a plain-language summary of its aim, methods, key findings and limitations.
Summarise with VIRAT Free to try with your Science Catalogs account.Abstract
This scientific article analyzes the decisions of Ukrainian courts and the European Court of Human Rights regarding compliance with the general principles of criminal proceedings in our state. It also identifies the causes and conditions that contribute to the violation of the principles of legality and independence of the judiciary. In particular, it has been established that in practice, there are still instances in Ukraine where participants in criminal proceedings representing the prosecution (Articles 36-41 of the Criminal Procedure Code) interfere with the process of making relevant judicial decisions, which are clearly illegal in nature. Instead of disregarding such actions by the pre-trial investigation bodies (primarily prosecutors exercising procedural guidance in these proceedings), the courts adopt the position of these subjects of the criminal process. Thus, they flagrantly violate the constitutional foundations of justice regarding the prohibition of delegating their functions to other state bodies and the rules of law concerning the independence of courts (Articles 124, 126 of the Basic Law of Ukraine). As shown by the research results, the European Court of Human Rights consistently emphasizes these facts in its decisions, noting that such a position of national courts acts as one of the determinants that causes and conditions the violation of rights, legitimate interests, and freedoms of humans and citizens in Ukraine. Based on the analysis conducted in this article, a number of scientifically substantiated conclusions, recommendations and other criminologically significant measures are formulated aimed at eliminating, blocking, neutralizing, etc. the determinant complex of causes and conditions that currently exist in our country, which contribute to any influence on courts and judges and, in this regard, violate their independence and inviolability, as well as cause citizens to appeal to the European Court of Human Rights for the restoration of their rights, legitimate interests and freedoms. In particular, it is proposed to enshrine in the current Code of Criminal Procedure special norms on the legal liability of judges and other participants in criminal proceedings for encroachment (influence, ignoring, self-influence, etc.) on the independence of the judiciary in Ukraine.
Fields of Study & Subjects
Ukrainian Legal and Forensic Studies
Judicial and Constitutional Studies
Legal processes and jurisprudence
Publication details
- Journal / source
- Uzhhorod National University Herald Series Law
- Volume
- 4
- Issue
- 93
- Pages
- 36–41
- Publication date
- 30 March 2026
- Language
- EN