The individual’s position regarding their own status as a “thief in law” and its significance for evidence

Read full text Summarise with VIRAT
Authors: О. В. Околіт
Cited by: 0
References: 1

Summary

No summary yet. VIRAT can read this paper and write a plain-language summary of its aim, methods, key findings and limitations.

Summarise with VIRAT Free to try with your Science Catalogs account.

Abstract

The article is devoted to the analysis of an individual’s position regarding their own status as a “thief in law” and to determining its significance for evidentiary purposes in criminal proceedings related to counteracting criminal influence. The relevance of the study is due to the complexity of establishing such a status, which lacks a formal legal definition, is not confirmed by official documents, and exists predominantly within the framework of criminal subculture. In law enforcement practice, this often leads to attempts to attribute independent evidentiary value to the accused’s position concerning the presence or absence of the relevant status. The article analyzes doctrinal approaches, investigative and judicial practice, as well as selected comparative legal aspects concerning the transformation of criminal subculture and changes in behavioral models of individuals occupying hierarchical positions in the criminal milieu. It substantiates the thesis that expecting a direct acknowledgment of the status of a “thief in law” is methodologically flawed, while silence, evasion of an answer, or denial of such status cannot be regarded as evidence against the person. It is demonstrated that an individual’s position regarding their own status may have significance only as a source of indicative information, which is subject to evaluation exclusively in conjunction with other evidence. Particular evidentiary value may be attributed to statements and actions recorded in the course of covert investigative (search) actions; however, these also cannot be assessed in isolation, without regard to context and the totality of other evidence. Similarly, recognition of the status by other persons is relevant only where it is confirmed by actual acts of subordination and execution of decisions, rather than by merely declarative forms of address. The article concludes that evidentiary activities in cases concerning criminal influence must be comprehensive and focused not on the formal confirmation of the status of a “thief in law,” but on establishing the actual content of the individual’s hierarchical role, the mechanisms of their influence, and the specific forms through which such influence is realized in behavior, in accordance with the principles of criminal proceedings and the requirements of legal certainty.

Fields of Study & Subjects

Legal processes and jurisprudence Criminal Law and Evidence Criminal Law and Policy

Publication details

Journal / source
Uzhhorod National University Herald Series Law
Volume
5
Issue
93
Pages
145–150
Publication date
31 March 2026
Language
EN