The patient’s right to refuse treatment as a manifestation of personal autonomy: some current issues
Summary
No summary yet. VIRAT can read this paper and write a plain-language summary of its aim, methods, key findings and limitations.
Summarise with VIRAT Free to try with your Science Catalogs account.Abstract
The article is devoted to the theoretical and legal analysis of some current issues of the patient’s right to refuse medical treatment and resuscitation measures as a manifestation of the principle of personal autonomy in the system of somatic human rights. The specified issues are considered at the intersection of medical law, bioethics, constitutional law and international human rights law, which determines its interdisciplinary nature and practical significance in the conditions of the rapid development of medical technologies. It is substantiated that the right to refuse medical intervention is a «negative» right, which is based on the doctrine of informed consent and the principle of respect for human dignity, and fundamentally differs from the «positive» right to receive medical care. It is emphasized that the paternalistic model of medicine is gradually being replaced by a partnership one, where the informed and free consent of the patient takes the central place, and the right to refuse treatment is its logical continuation. The issue of refusal of resuscitation measures is investigated, including the legal status of DNR orders and the institution of advance directives. The peculiarities of the legal status of incapacitated persons and the mechanisms for making medical decisions in their favor by relatives or authorized representatives are considered. The practice of the European Court of Human Rights in the cases of Arskaya v. Ukraine (2013), Lambert v. France (2015) and Pindo Mulla v. Spain (2024) is analyzed, which formed key standards regarding the positive obligations of the state in the field of medical law and respect for patient autonomy. A comparative legal analysis of approaches to the legislative regulation of the right to refuse treatment in the USA, EU member states and Ukraine is carried out. It is established that domestic legislation does not contain a systematic mechanism for the patient’s advance written expression of will, which creates legal uncertainty and makes it impossible to actually exercise the right to self-determination in critical medical situations. Based on the results of the study, proposals were formulated regarding the legislative consolidation of the institution of a medical will (living will) and the mechanism for appointing a medical representative (health-care proxy) in Ukrainian law, taking into account international standards and the experience of foreign legal systems.
Fields of Study & Subjects
Medical and Health Sciences Research
Ethics and bioethics in healthcare
Health
Medicine and Society
Publication details
- Journal / source
- Uzhhorod National University Herald Series Law
- Volume
- 5
- Issue
- 93
- Pages
- 475–483
- Publication date
- 31 March 2026
- Language
- EN