Strategic Intent Investigation of Motto in the Hierarchy Together with Vision and Mission in Public Sector of National Departments in South Africa

Read full text Summarise with VIRAT
Authors: Tshililo Thomas Radzilani
Cited by: 0

Summary

No summary yet. VIRAT can read this paper and write a plain-language summary of its aim, methods, key findings and limitations.

Summarise with VIRAT Free to try with your Science Catalogs account.

Abstract

The study examined the position of motto statements within the strategic planning hierarchy of South Africa's national departments, investigating their strategic intent alongside vision and mission statements. Although government entities have increasingly adopted branding-oriented expressions similar to those used in the private sector, the functional role of mottos within public-sector planning remains poorly defined. This gap is particularly evident given the absence of empirical research assessing whether mottos align with legislative mandates, macro-policy priorities, or organizational identity frameworks. The research, therefore, sought to determine the degree of congruence, convergence, and alignment among vision, mission, and motto statements, and to establish the extent to which public servants are aware of, interpret, and utilize these statements as part of strategic execution. A mixed-methods design was employed. The population comprised all 39 national departments, from which archival data were extracted for content and readability analysis. Quantitative data were collected through self-administered questionnaires distributed to 400 middle-management and operational staff, yielding 123 usable responses. Qualitative data were obtained from 21 in-depth interviews with senior managers. Instruments included a structured questionnaire measuring awareness, ranking, and perceived strategic relevance of statements, and an interview guide focusing on interpretation, use, and strategic meaning. Analysis combined descriptive statistics, ranking procedures, content analysis using Voyant Tools, readability assessment through the Gunning Fog Index, and thematic coding in NVivo. Findings indicated that 95% of participants believed their departments should have all three statements, yet mottos appeared in only 41% of national departments. Across the hierarchy of strategic statements, the Constitution ranked highest (54%), followed by legal mandate (38%), with vision (24%), values (18%), NDP (16%), mission (14%), and motto (6%) in descending order. Despite low ranking, some interviewees described mottos as potentially unifying or motivational, though no evidence showed that they shaped operational behavior or service-delivery outcomes. The results reveal partial alignment between statements, limited convergence across clusters, and minimal integration between mottos and departmental mandates. The study contributes to public-sector strategic management by clarifying the symbolic and operational boundaries of motto statements within government planning frameworks. It highlights the need to recalibrate strategic hierarchy models toward constitutional and legislative primacy while critically reconsidering whether mottos warrant formalization in planning instruments without demonstrated strategic value.

Fields of Study & Subjects

Organizational Strategy and Culture Public Policy and Administration Research Public Administration in Developing Nations

Publication details

Journal / source
The International Journal of Business & Management
Publication date
12 February 2026
Language
EN