Punishing Desire: Female Adultery and Patriarchal Justice from Puritan America to Modern India

Adultery has historically functioned as a deeply gendered moral category, with women subjected to harsher scrutiny, punishment, and social regulation than men. This paper undertakes a comparative feminist analysis of The Scarlet Letter by Nathaniel Hawthorne and A Married Woman by Manju Kapur to examine how patriarchal societies across two distinct eras and cultures discipline female sexual transgression. Although separated by more than a century, divergent cultural contexts, and different narrative modes, both novels reveal a striking continuity in the moral double standards governing adultery. Female desire is rendered visible, punishable, and socially destabilising, while male transgression is concealed, excused, or institutionally protected. The paper argues that adultery in these texts functions less as a moral failing and more as a mechanism through which patriarchal authority asserts control over female autonomy. By analysing public punishment, moral surveillance, and gendered accountability, this study demonstrates how patriarchal justice adapts its methods while preserving its fundamental logic. Keywords: adultery, gendered morality, patriarchy, feminist criticism, Hawthorne, Manju Kapur