Simulation of Visual Ternary Comparisons to Increase the Reliability of Collective Decisions in the VisTerComp Environment

Read full text Summarise with VIRAT
Authors: V.V. ZUBKO, V.V. Kolodnyi
Cited by: 0
References: 7

Summary

No summary yet. VIRAT can read this paper and write a plain-language summary of its aim, methods, key findings and limitations.

Summarise with VIRAT Free to try with your Science Catalogs account.

Abstract

The analysis of a real dataset obtained using the VisTerComp web application developed by the authors was conducted, and two manifestations of unprofessionalism and expert dishonesty were identified: passivity of experts and randomness of the sassessments (H-manifestations). To study and reduce the negative impact of unreliable results of individual experts on the overall collective results of ranking alternatives, approaches to simulation modeling were developed and the corresponding simulation module was designed and implemented in the VisTerComp environment. Series of simulation experiments with zero and random visual ternary comparisons in different ratios were planned and conducted. Based on the analysis of the simulation results, tolerance areas in the space of parameters of passivity and contradiction of opinions for a different number of alternatives were determined. In order to increase the reliability of collective expert results and protect against H-manifestations in the VisTerComp information technology, a comparison of the calculated values of the indicators of incompetence, contradiction of opinions and passivity of experts with the specified maximum permissible values was proposed. Recommendations have been developed for selecting parameter values from tolerance areas, which allow filtering out unreliable individual results of experts with H-manifestations with a probability of up to 99%. A new option for excluding unreliable individual results has been proposed and implemented in the VisTerComp web application, which allows comparing the corresponding more reliable collective results of the examination with the general results for all experts. Further implementation of the VisTerComp web application in practice and in the educational process is planned for the purpose of the in-depth study of the impact of new options and settings on the reliability of collective expert decisions when using the information technology of ranking alternatives based on visual ternary comparisons.

Fields of Study & Subjects

Multi-Criteria Decision Making Decision Support System Applications Game Theory and Voting Systems

Publication details

Journal / source
Visnyk of Vinnytsia Politechnical Institute
Volume
184
Issue
1
Pages
116–123
Publication date
1 January 2026
Language
EN