Review of: "The Role of Artificial Intelligence in the Lifecycle of Scientific Manuscripts: Authoring, Reviewing, and Editorial Selection"

The corrections suggested below are based on version 1 of the publication.I have reviewed the second version of the manuscript and acknowledge the author's efforts to clarify the genre (now positioned as critical commentary) and to introduce nuances regarding non-commercial journals and legal responsibility.These improvements are welcome.However, the substantial technical and economic shortcomings identi ed in my evaluation of the earlier version remain entirely unaddressed.