Review of: "Does Palaeolithic Resource Management Leading to Domestication Explain Human “Modernity”?"
Abstract
I thank you for offering me the opportunity to review this article.I would like to clarify that I am Antoine Balzeau.The title of this article caught my attention, which is why I agreed to review it.The proposed work lacks structure.It provides no data, and the discussion does not contextualize the state of knowledge on the topics addressed.At best, it gives the impression of listing a few data points on animal groups without ever truly contextualizing them.There is no structuring of the argument, no justi cation.Many concepts are introduced without ever being de ned.The author merely unfolds a line of reasoning that supports their own views without ever demonstrating them.
Fields of Study & Subjects
Archaeology and ancient environmental studies
Pleistocene-Era Hominins and Archaeology
Language and cultural evolution
Publication details
- Publication date
- 14 January 2026