A Note on Hempel's Paradox

Read full text
Authors: Alfonso Di Prospero
Cited by: 0

Abstract

In this paper, Hempel’s paradox is revisited, a paradox that arises from the observation of a black raven which inductively confirms the generalization “All ravens are black”, but can also be interpreted as supporting the statement “All swans are white”. The proposed resolution leverages the non-monotonic nature of inductive inference, suggesting that two distinct inferences from the same observation are not required to yield the same outcome. This exploration underscores the importance of the non-monotonic nature of induction, hinting at its reflection of the contextual and situated nature of human knowledge. There are many underlying epistemological questions that I do not consider here for the sake of simplicity. I have dealt with them in previous works. Of course all these remarks are only a sketch of a better developed theory that is still to be realized.

Fields of Study & Subjects

Epistemology Ethics and Metaphysics Philosophy and History of Science Philosophy and Theoretical Science

Publication details

Journal / source
Qeios
Publication date
8 January 2026
Document type
Preprint