Review of: "Superexcitability in Chiral Oscillators with Spatial Degrees of Freedom"

Overview I read v2 carefully and had drafted detailed review notes.Before posting them, I noticed that the author had already uploaded v3 with substantial proactive revisions.In particular, the introduction of the macroscopic order parameter $S$ to characterize phase-momentum locking, and the inclusion of a baseline basin analysis for the $N=2$ case in Appendix A, align closely with the main directions I had planned to recommend.These updates signi cantly improve the manuscript's self-consistency, reproducibility, and narrative clarity.Building on this strengthened v3, I provide below a concise set of remaining comments aimed at further polishing the current version.