CORRUPTION AS A SOCIO-LEGAL CONSTRAINT ON ACCESS TO JUSTICE: A COMPARATIVE INTEGRITY REVIEW OF KAZAKHSTAN AND SELECTED EASTERN EUROPEAN JURISDICTIONS (2019–2025)

Read full text Summarise with VIRAT
Authors: Victor Nikolaevich ZHAMULDINOV
Cited by: 0
References: 19

Summary

No summary yet. VIRAT can read this paper and write a plain-language summary of its aim, methods, key findings and limitations.

Summarise with VIRAT Free to try with your Science Catalogs account.

Abstract

Background: In post-socialist legal systems in Kazakhstan and several Eastern European states, corruption continues to pose a systemic challenge to the rule of law and to effective access to justice. In this article, corruption is treated as a socio-legal phenomenon sustained by recurring administrative and judicial decision-making routines and societal patterns of legality, including trust in institutions. These mechanisms jointly condition how rights are enforced in practice and whether courts are perceived as credible. When judicial independence is weakened and civic-legal consciousness is low, corruption does not mechanically determine outcomes, but it increases the probability that informal influence can enter decision-making routines and erode procedural equality, predictability, and the credibility of adjudication. While some governance systems may partially offset this risk through effective controls in adjacent institutions, the justice sector is less amenable to compensation, as courts constitute the final enforcement and rights-protection forum. Therefore, the analysis focuses on the judiciary not as the sole locus of corruption, but as the critical channel through which corruption converts into practical constraints on access to justice via reduced predictability, weaker procedural equality, and lower credibility of adjudication. Understanding corruption through the prism of access to justice requires attention to its legal, cultural, and institutional foundations. Methods: The study applies a socio-legal (law-and-society) analytical review combining comparative legal analysis with mechanism-oriented socio-legal synthesis and qualitative content analysis. The evidence base consists of national legislation, international anti-corruption and rule-of-law instruments (UNCAC, OECD, GRECO), selected judicial practice, and analytical reports of Transparency International and the UNDP. A structured comparison of Kazakhstan with the Eastern European jurisdictions of Poland, Lithuania, and the Czech Republic is conducted to assess how legal culture, institutional autonomy, and civic oversight affect corruption control and access to justice. Results and Conclusions: The findings reveal a direct relationship between the level of corruption, the operational legal culture, and the practical accessibility of justice. Where judicial safeguards are operational and externally verifiable, transparency becomes actionable: reasoned decisions are publicly accessible, and participation channels are usable. Under these conditions, tolerance of corruption declines and trust in courts is more likely to increase. The article introduces the Socio-Legal Integrity Framework, which integrates legal education, cultural transformation, and institutional accountability as interconnected mechanisms shaping anti-corruption legal consciousness. For Kazakhstan, the analysis underscores the need to strengthen the autonomy of anti-corruption bodies, enhance external oversight of the judiciary, expand meaningful digital transparency, and embed value-oriented legal education. In contrast, several Eastern European states demonstrate more advanced preventive approaches grounded in participatory governance and enforceable judicial ethics. The study concludes that effective anti-corruption policy requires not only formal legal reform but also a systemic reconfiguration of legal culture to ensure genuine access to justice.

Fields of Study & Subjects

Corruption and Economic Development Judicial and Constitutional Studies Law Economics and Judicial Systems

Publication details

Journal / source
Access to Justice in Eastern Europe
Publication date
30 March 2026
Language
EN