Perceptions and Preferences of Malaysian Secondary Students on Teachers’ Written Corrective Feedback

Read full text Summarise with VIRAT
Authors: Wirawati Yi Xe Ngui, Anne Anthonia Federick
Cited by: 0
References: 17

Summary

No summary yet. VIRAT can read this paper and write a plain-language summary of its aim, methods, key findings and limitations.

Summarise with VIRAT Free to try with your Science Catalogs account.

Abstract

Even after years of studying the language, second language (L2) learners continue to make frequent grammatical mistakes in their writing, regardless of their proficiency level. Teachers help them reduce these writing mistakes through several strategies, one of which is written corrective feedback (WCF). This study explored the types of WCF employed by English teachers and examined students’ perceptions and preferences regarding such feedback. The research, which involved 68 upper-secondary students, was conducted at a rural school in Sabah, Malaysia and adopted an explanatory sequential mixed-methods design. Data were collected through content analysis of 33 student essays, a questionnaire comprising Likert-scale and open-ended items, and semi-structured interviews with three students. Findings revealed that teachers primarily used Direct WCF, while Indirect ones were applied less frequently, and Metalinguistic feedback was not used at all. Overall, students found WCF to be clear and helpful, particularly in addressing grammar and verb tense issues, though some expressed uncertainty about its impact on their long-term writing development. The majority preferred Direct WCF for its clarity, immediacy, and effectiveness in reducing repeated errors, as supported by thematic analysis of interview data, which revealed students’ preference for straightforward corrections that enhance comprehension and retention. These results suggest that aligning WCF practices with learners’ preferences can strengthen engagement and writing performance. The study contributes valuable insights for ESL educators seeking to optimise WCF strategies in secondary education settings, particularly in underrepresented regionsEven after years of studying the language, second language (L2) learners continue to make frequent grammatical mistakes in their writing, regardless of their proficiency level. Teachers help them reduce these writing mistakes through several strategies, one of which is written corrective feedback (WCF). This study explored the types of WCF employed by English teachers and examined students’ perceptions and preferences regarding such feedback. The research, which involved 68 upper-secondary students, was conducted at a rural school in Sabah, Malaysia and adopted an explanatory sequential mixed-methods design. Data were collected through content analysis of 33 student essays, a questionnaire comprising Likert-scale and open-ended items, and semi-structured interviews with three students. Findings revealed that teachers primarily used Direct WCF, while Indirect ones were applied less frequently, and Metalinguistic feedback was not used at all. Overall, students found WCF to be clear and helpful, particularly in addressing grammar and verb tense issues, though some expressed uncertainty about its impact on their long-term writing development. The majority preferred Direct WCF for its clarity, immediacy, and effectiveness in reducing repeated errors, as supported by thematic analysis of interview data, which revealed students’ preference for straightforward corrections that enhance comprehension and retention. These results suggest that aligning WCF practices with learners’ preferences can strengthen engagement and writing performance. The study contributes valuable insights for ESL educators seeking to optimise WCF strategies in secondary education settings, particularly in underrepresented regions

Fields of Study & Subjects

EFL/ESL Teaching and Learning Student Assessment and Feedback Second Language Acquisition and Learning

Publication details

Journal / source
Jurnal Pendidikan
Volume
27
Issue
1
Pages
11–21
Publication date
28 March 2026
Language
EN