Commentary: Going beyond frontiers in household energy transition in Poland—a perspective

Read full text Summarise with VIRAT
Authors: Jakub Kubiczek, Amelia Bochenek, Aleksandra Kaliszuk, Stella Suljić Nikolaj
Cited by: 0
References: 12

Summary

No summary yet. VIRAT can read this paper and write a plain-language summary of its aim, methods, key findings and limitations.

Summarise with VIRAT Free to try with your Science Catalogs account.

Abstract

The transition toward sustainable development in the energy context represents one of the most significant challenges facing the modern world. Current forecasts emphasize the rapid pace of the global energy transition. According to the International Energy Agency (IEA 2024) global renewable capacity is expected to grow by 2.7 times by 2030, surpassing countries' current ambitions by nearly 25%, yet still falling short of tripling. Although the development of renewable energy sources (RES) is expected to mitigate climate change, their efficiency remains highly dependent on weather conditions, which poses a challenge to the stability of the energy system (International Monetary Fund. European Dept., 2023). Moreover, accelerating climate change-manifested in increasingly dynamic weather phenomena-already significantly constrains the energy transition process.Households play a crucial role in advancing sustainable development, acting as prosumers who actively contribute to the energy transition through their behaviors and investments (Trębska et al., 2024). Understanding the barriers to transformation is particularly important in countries whose economies have relied on coal for decades and whose societies remain strongly attached to traditional energy sources. Kubiczek et al. (2023) identified such barriers in the case of Poland-an economy in which, as of 2022, coal still accounted for 41.84% of total electricity production. This commentary seeks to evaluate the contemporary relevance and validity of the challenges and frontiers identified in the study in view of updated socio-economic data and shifts in geopolitical risk.The energy transition in Poland has accelerated markedly over the past two years, with a significant decline in hard coal consumption across the economy. Compared to 2023, coal use fell by 14%, and relative to 2015, by as much as 33% in terms of energy production (Forum Energii, 2025). The share of coal in Poland's energy mix began to decrease visibly after 2021, coinciding with a dynamic increase in renewable energy installations.According to the International Energy Agency (2024) this downward trend is expected to slow in the coming years, as investments in renewables approach their target levels. Moreover, forecasts suggest that in other EU countries, the upward trend in renewable capacity will continue, potentially leaving Poland less advanced in terms of its overall energy transition progress. Renewable energy installations in Poland are predominantly prosumer-based and implemented through small-scale systems. Studies show that 69.4% of households do not intend to undertake any form of energy transition, and among those that do, 72.0% opt for photovoltaic panels (Trębska et al., 2024). This reluctance stems not only from a strong attachment to coal-based traditions (Burzyńska, 2023;Hadasik et al., 2025), but also from an insufficient incentive structure. Experts argue that the recent slowdown in renewable deployment may be linked to government-imposed electricity price freezes (IEO, 2024). This aligns with Hadasik et al. (2025), who show that Polish households are likely to engage in the transition primarily in response to economic incentives and increasing energy-carrier prices.Against this backdrop, the share of renewables may accelerate with the implementation of ETS2 and RED III, which can strengthen incentives for investment in renewable energy sources (Żuk & Żuk, 2023). At the same time, ETS2 may raise the cost of fossil-fuel-based heating, disproportionately affecting low-income households. As emphasized by Żuk and Żuk (2024), these policy changes should therefore be accompanied by targeted protective measures to prevent a deepening of energy poverty, particularly among vulnerable groups such as seniors.Electricity and heating already constitute the second-largest expenditure category in Polish household budgets after food, and their share exceeds the EU average (Forum Energii, 2025). From an energy security perspective, renewables are increasingly important for supply stability, especially amid heightened geopolitical tensions (Burzyńska, 2023). The European Union does not fully meet its own energy demand, and import dependence reached 60.6%, creating risks for supply security (Rabbi et al., 2022). In Poland, energy import dependency has been rising, increasing reliance on external suppliers, limiting price autonomy, and elevating the risk of supply disruptions when domestic generation falls short (Kubiczek et al., 2025). The scale of this phenomenon is evident in 2024, when Poland recorded net electricity imports amounting to 1,965.8 GWh (PSE, 2025).Buildings account for around 40% of final energy consumption in the EU and 36% of energy-related greenhouse gas emissions, while about 75% of the building stock remains energy-inefficient. At the same time, Poland is seeing a dynamic rise in electricity demand, largely driven by the expansion of new single-family housing (Forum Energii, 2024), which creates a window of opportunity for scaling renewables by integrating installations at the construction stage, rather than retrofitting existing buildings. Furthermore, Niewiadomski (2025) emphasizes that rural areas possess the greatest locational potential for renewables due to dispersed housing patterns and greater land availability, which favor both photovoltaic systems and the development of small wind farms.Poland still lacks a coherent vision for renewable energy development, including regulations that would enable efficient and streamlined installation processes. Comprehensive support programs are also missing, while the abundance of fragmented initiatives may, paradoxically, discourage potential participants. Kubiczek et al. (2023) highlight the issue of unutilized financial resources, whichaccording to recent studies-remains a significant problem. Only 25% of the 103 billion PLN budget of Poland's largest pro-ecological initiative ,,Czyste Powietrze had been utilized as of 12 April 2024(NFOŚiGW, 2024). On the other hand, Kot (2025) observes that renewable energy in Poland is still predominantly represented by photovoltaics, with the number of installations increasing from 0.15 million in 2019 to 1.2 million in 2024. Financial support has been provided to both households and enterprises, confirming that economic incentives constitute the key factor motivating Poles to engage in the energy transition (Burzyńska, 2023;Hadasik et al., 2025). Additionally, policies supporting RES investments, especially preferential loans, can significantly enhance economic profitability for enterprises, supporting sustainable development (Hou et al., 2025).Despite the growing number of initiatives supporting RES in Poland, many of the barriers discussed in the referenced article still seem to apply. Recent research continues to show a strong social attachment to coal and only weakly rooted pro-environmental attitudes, which slows the transition. This suggests a gap between policy ambition and the pace at which households and communities actually change preferences and behaviors. Evidence also remains clear that financial incentives, especially grants, tax reliefs, and access to public funds, are among the strongest drivers of RES adoption.The main weakness is the fragmented and unstable nature of support. Many programs operate in short cycles, with frequent rule changes and limited coordination across instruments, which increases uncertainty and discourages long-term investment decisions. Energy policy should therefore be more coherent and predictable, embedded in a long-term roadmap rather than short-term, politically driven interventions. Absent such stability, the transition may generate adverse outcomes, including investment volatility, weakening public support, and an increased risk of energy poverty. Importantly, "protective measures" should be operationalized through specific instruments, such as direct cash transfers indexed to household energy expenditure or deep energy retrofit vouchers for low-income households financed from ETS2 revenues.A phased policy design that aligns decarbonization objectives with affordability constraints and grid readiness would be more likely to sustain RES investment and strengthen social acceptance in Poland. In practice, this argues for one integrated, long-term program rather than a patchwork of short-lived measures, supported by a high-visibility information campaign and tailored pathways that reflect the diversity of Polish households. Crucially, price-freezing of this kind should not be used as a long-term strategy, because it weakens incentives to save energy and invest; instead, targeted protection for vulnerable groups should be combined with stable rules and financing that keep the transition both fair and effective.The authors declare that the research was conducted in the absence of any commercial or financial relationships that could be construed as a potential conflict of interest.Jakub Kubiczek -conceptualization, methodology, article preparation (writing -original draft), validation, supervision.Amelia Bochenek -literature review, text revision (writing -review & editing).Aleksandra Kaliszuk -literature review, text revision (writing -review & editing).Stella Suljic Nikolaj -text revision (writing -review & editing).The author(s) declare that financial support was received for the research and/or publication of this article. This paper has been written within the scope of the project "

Fields of Study & Subjects

Renewable Energy and Sustainability Renewable energy and sustainable power systems Social Acceptance of Renewable Energy

Publication details

Journal / source
Frontiers in Energy Research
Volume
14
Publication date
30 March 2026
Language
EN