International standards and good practice guidelines in traditional, complementary and integrative medicine: a scoping review

Read full text
Authors: Xuanbin Wang, Hongliang Li, Shun Jiang, Nian Yang, Dongpeng Wang, Hongxi Xu, Nicola Robinson, L. F. Shyur, Michael Heinrich, Mei Wang, Monique S. J. Simmonds, Linda L. D. Zhong
+8 more Fatiha Brahmi, Thomas Efferth, Salvius Amuri Bakari, Clara Bik-San Lau, Wendy W. Wong, Rudolf Bauer, Pierre Duez, Qihe Xu
Cited by: 2
References: 95

Abstract

Objectives: To map the development of international standards (IS) and international good practice guidelines (IGPG) across the field of traditional, complementary and integrative medicine (TCIM) and establish a comprehensive repository. Methods: A systematic search was conducted using PubMed, Web of Science, EMBASE, ProQuest, and the Cochrane Library, as well as relevant websites, with the assistance of artificial intelligence tools. This search combined MeSH terms and keywords, and was further supplemented by non-systematic human expert input, covering the period from January 2000 to April 2025. Duplicates were removed and all records were screened based on pre-defined criteria for TCIM-relevant IS/IGPG and TCIM- and IS/IGPG-related systematic reviews, implementation documents and commentaries. Findings: 2026 records met inclusion criteria: (a) TCIM-relevant IS/IGPG documents (n = 1,624); and (b) TCIM- and IS/IGPG-related secondary documents (systematic reviews, perspectives and commentaries, n = 402). These IS/IGPG were produced by 33 international organisations and consortia, broadly applicable to TCIM or specific to a particular TCIM modality. Our data showed acceleration in IS/IGPG production over the past two decades. An analysis of the secondary literature provided a broad overview of the disease spectrum and the application of IS/IGPG in TCIM studies. Conclusion: A comprehensive repository for TCIM-related IS/IGPG has been established. These IS/IGPG can be expected to play important roles for an efficient implementation of the World Health Organization Traditional Medicine Strategy 2025-2034. Future work should focus on disseminating, implementing and harmonising these IS/IGPG, evaluating their effectiveness and refining them, while promoting global parity in access, implementation and coverage. Study Registration: The Open Science Framework (https://doi.org/10.17605/OSF.IO/H8UFM).

Fields of Study & Subjects

Complementary and Alternative Medicine Studies Traditional Chinese Medicine Studies Clinical practice guidelines implementation

Publication details

Journal / source
Frontiers in Pharmacology
Publisher
Frontiers Media SA
Volume
17
Pages
1742400–1742400
Publication date
9 April 2026
Language
EN