Comparative Effects of Amendment Practices on Soil Quality, Crop Productivity, and Ecosystem Services in Arid Saline–Alkali Farmland: A Three-Year Field Study

Soil salinization severely constrains crop productivity and ecosystem services in arid regions. While the application of soil amendments represents a promising mitigation strategy, it remains uncertain whether this practice can effectively enhance soil quality index (SQI), crop productivity, and ecosystem service value (ESV) in saline–alkali farmlands. To address this, a three-year field experiment was conducted to analyze the effects of different amendments (rotary-tilled straw return (RT), plowed straw return (PL), biochar (BC), desulfurized gypsum (DG), DG combined with organic fertilizer (DGO), and an unamended control (CK)) on SQI, sunflower productivity, and ESV in a saline–alkali farmland of arid Northwest China. Results indicated that the BC treatment significantly reduced bulk density by 5.1–7.6% and increased porosity by 6.3–8.3% compared to CK. Both BC and DGO significantly increased soil organic matter and available nutrients while reducing saline ions (HCO3−, Cl−, Na+), which reduced soil salinity by 21.2–33.6% and 19.9–26.5%, respectively. These synergistic improvements enhanced the SQI by 76.8% and 74.1% for BC and DGO, respectively, relative to CK. Correlation analysis revealed strong positive relationships between SQI and crop nitrogen uptake and yield. Accordingly, BC and DGO increased nitrogen uptake by 74.9–129.0% and yield by 12.2–45.2%, with BC offering more stable benefits over time. Furthermore, BC increased the values of agricultural product supply, nutrient accumulation and climate regulation, thereby increasing the total ESV by 13.7–53.9% relative to CK. In summary, BC and DGO are effective strategies to synergistically enhance soil quality, crop productivity, and ecosystem services in saline–alkali farmlands of arid regions.