Replacing Glyphosate Shifts Environmental Burdens: Trade-Offs Between Ecotoxicity and Climate Impact in Chemical and Non-Chemical Strategies

The potential withdrawal of glyphosate necessitates a comprehensive evaluation of alternative weed control strategies that balances human health safety with environmental concerns. This study applied a decision-support grid to compare the impacts of glyphosate-based reference strategies against chemical and non-chemical alternatives across four Belgian case studies: pome fruit orchards, grassland renewal, arable weed patches, and railways. The assessment integrated twelve risk indicators including human, environmental and biodiversity risk, and life cycle assessment for global warming potential (GWP) into a Final Scenario Score (FSS). The results indicated that only one alternative strategy, the chemical alternative in local weed patch control, achieved the FSS threshold (