Spatiotemporal Evolution and Deformation Mechanism of Deep Foundation Excavation in Water-Rich Sand Strata: A Comparative Study of Monitoring and Simulation

Deep foundation excavation in water-rich sand strata presents complex deformation characteristics driven by fluid–solid interaction, which distinguishes it from excavations in cohesive soft clay. This study investigates the spatiotemporal evolution and deformation mechanisms of retaining structures through a comparative analysis of field monitoring data and 3D numerical simulation, based on a subway station project in Xi’an. While the numerical simulation predicted a continuous “bulging” deformation mode, field monitoring revealed a distinct transition from a “bulging” profile to a “step-like” deformation pattern as the excavation deepened. Quantitatively, while the simulation captured the spatial trend, the measured maximum surface settlement (7.8 mm) exceeded the simulated value (1.2 mm), highlighting the dominant role of seepage consolidation. Detailed analysis indicates that this discrepancy—and the unique step-like evolution—is primarily driven by two mechanisms: the rapid stress relaxation of cohesionless sand during the time lag of support installation, and the superimposed seepage forces induced by continuous dewatering, which are often simplified in standard elastoplastic models. The study further identifies that the vertical displacement of the pile top is governed by the combined effects of basal heave and the “kick-out” deformation at the pile toe. These findings demonstrate that in high-permeability water-rich sand, deformation control depends critically on minimizing the unsupported exposure time of the excavation face. This research provides a theoretical basis for optimizing the spatiotemporal sequencing of excavation in similar geological conditions.