Assessment of the Relationship Between Seismic Vulnerability and Seismic Risk Perception: A Case Study of Peshawar, Pakistan

Earthquakes pose a serious threat to urban areas located in seismically active regions, particularly in developing countries where rapid urbanization and weak enforcement of building regulations increase the vulnerability of the built environment. Pakistan is highly exposed to seismic hazards due to its tectonic setting, and many residential buildings are constructed without adequate seismic design considerations. Therefore, assessing building vulnerability and understanding community perception of earthquake risk are essential for effective disaster risk reduction. This study investigates the relationship between the structural vulnerability of residential buildings and earthquake risk perception among residents in Peshawar, Pakistan. Two contrasting urban settlements were selected as case studies: WAPDA Town, representing a planned residential area, and Hashtnagri, representing an older unplanned settlement. A total of 400 buildings were surveyed through field investigations. Seismic vulnerability was assessed using the Rapid Visual Screening (RVS) method based on structural characteristics such as building age, number of floors, construction materials, structural irregularities, construction quality, and presence of seismic reinforcement features. A Physical Vulnerability Index (PVI) was developed to categorize buildings into different vulnerability levels. In addition, a questionnaire survey was conducted to evaluate earthquake risk perception among residents, and a risk perception index (RPI) was calculated. The results indicate that buildings located in the unplanned settlement exhibit significantly higher seismic vulnerability compared to those in the planned residential area due to poor construction practices, irregular structural configurations, and the absence of seismic-resistant features. Statistical analysis further reveals a positive relationship between physical vulnerability and earthquake risk perception, suggesting that residents living in structurally vulnerable environments tend to perceive higher earthquake risk. The findings highlight the importance of integrating structural vulnerability assessment with community awareness and preparedness programs. Implementation of seismic design provisions and improved enforcement of construction regulations, such as those specified in the Building Code of Pakistan 2022, can significantly reduce earthquake risk in rapidly growing urban areas. However, the present study did not directly evaluate the level of enforcement or compliance with the Building Code of Pakistan 2022 in either WAPDA Town or Hashtnagri. Therefore, the policy recommendations are intended as general implications derived from the observed vulnerability patterns.