Improving Establishment of Christmas Tree Plantations: Case Studies from the Great Lakes and Pacific Northwest

Christmas tree growers are concerned with improving establishment of their plantations. Here, we report the results of a series of on-farm trials conducted with grower-cooperators in the Pacific Northwest (PNW) and Great Lakes (Michigan—MI) regions to determine the efficacy of treatments at planting on improving tree survival and growth in Christmas tree plantations. Cooperating growers planted species that were typical for each region (Fraser fir in the Great Lakes and Douglas-fir and noble fir in the PNW) and managed the plantings using standard cultural practices, aside from test treatments. Test treatments varied between locations and years but included wood chip mulch, shade blocks, an anti-transpirant, biochar, fertilizers, and various root dips including polymer gels, mycorrhizae, and bio-stimulants. Overall, treatments that directly modified the tree environment (i.e., mulch and shade blocks) provided the most consistent benefit to tree survival and growth. In Michigan, mulching increased survival by 5% on non-irrigated farms and increased second-year shoot growth by ~3 cm. In the PNW trials, mulching increased survival of noble fir seedlings more than Douglas-fir seedlings. Installing controlled release fertilizer packets at planting increased initial growth of Douglas-firs. Application of root dips prior to planting did not improve tree survival or growth relative to dipping tree roots in water (control). Based on our results, we conclude that treatments that conserve soil moisture (mulch) or reduce tree water loss (shade blocks) offer the most direct opportunity for growers to improve initial tree survival and growth.