Hypolimnetic Aeration Versus Predatory Fish Stocking to Address Water Quality Parameters: A Case Study from Four Czech Reservoirs

Limnological parameters were monitored in four highland reservoirs in the Czech Republic from 2022 to 2024 to evaluate the effects of management practices on water quality. Although the reservoirs share similar morphometry and all serve as drinking water sources, they differ in trophic status and management: Hubenov (HU, eutrophic) is stocked with piscivores, Nová Říše (NŘ, mesotrophic) undergoes hypolimnetic aeration, and Landštejn (LA, meso-oligotrophic) and Mostiště (MO, eutrophic) receive no targeted management interventions. Limnological data were collected monthly from April to October along vertical profiles in dam parts of the reservoirs. Comparisons were performed using graphical presentation and linear mixed-effects models. Analyses of abiotic (thermal, oxygen, and pH stratification, transparency, total phosphorus (TP) and nitrogen (TN) concentrations) and biotic (algae chlorophyll-a, cyanobacterial pigments, zooplankton density and composition) variables revealed that HU and MO exhibited the lowest transparency (on average 1.9 m in both in contrast to 2.2 m and 2.8 m in NŘ and LA, respectively) and highest seasonal algae chlorophyll-a concentrations (11.4 µg/L in HU and 15.1 µg/L in MO in contrast to 6.4 µg/L in NŘ and 5.5 µg/L in LA), indicating negligible improvement from biomanipulation. In contrast, NŘ demonstrated nutrient and chlorophyll-a levels comparable to LA (TP: 0.010 mg/L and 0.009 mg/L, TN: 1.591 mg/L and 0.419 mg/L, in NŘ and LA, respectively), despite higher nutrient input, and achieved the second highest transparency. Zooplankton densities were similar across reservoirs, supporting the hypothesis of bottom-up control or insufficient piscivore impact. These findings highlight the importance of reducing nutrient inputs to preserve water quality. Hypolimnetic aeration, which enhances sediment nutrient retention, appears more effective at mitigating eutrophication and controlling algal proliferation than fish stocking, a commonly applied biomanipulation approach.