MODELS OF GOVERNANCE FOR COMMERCIAL SPACE PROGRAMS: A COMPARATIVE ANALYSIS OF INDIA AND CHINA

View at publisher Summarise with VIRAT
Authors: Petr Punchenko
Cited by: 0

Summary

No summary yet. VIRAT can read this paper and write a plain-language summary of its aim, methods, key findings and limitations.

Summarise with VIRAT Free to try with your Science Catalogs account.

Abstract

This paper presents a comparative analysis of governance models for commercial space programs in India and China, representing two distinct institutional approaches within the BRICS context. Amidst the commercialization of space activities in the 2020s, the focus shifts from technical metrics to governance mechanisms: the allocation of functions between the state and private enterprises, regulatory frameworks for private access to infrastructure, financing instruments, and data management regimes. The Indian model, formalized in the Indian Space Policy 2023, is built on the principle of functional separation. ISRO acts as a technology donor, NSIL functions as the commercial arm, and IN-SPACe serves as a single-window clearance mechanism, ensuring transparent private sector access to facilities and testing. A critical tool is the transition from “capacity procurement” to “service procurement,” where the state acts as an anchor tenant for data and communication services, fostering the growth of downstream applications. In contrast, the Chinese model embodies an integrated industrial policy where the commercial sector is embedded within state-owned corporate groups and national programs. Space is viewed as a platform for the digital economy, with commercialization driven by large-scale projects, stringent standardization, and controlled liberalization. This is exemplified by private launch companies like LandSpace, which operate successfully within state-defined strategic priorities. The comparative analysis reveals that the Indian approach cultivates a “market through rules” (emphasizing contractor competition and reduced entry barriers), while the Chinese approach fosters a “market through scale” (relying on serial production and state procurement). For BRICS nations, the most viable pathway is a hybrid model: adopting India’s service-procurement and open infrastructure model while integrating China’s platform standardization and supply chain cooperation. The paper concludes that the success of commercialization hinges not on the degree of privatization, but on the quality of institutional design — the state’s capacity to simultaneously generate demand, lower transaction costs, and maintain control over critical technologies and data.

Fields of Study & Subjects

Space exploration and regulation Space Technology and Applications Space Satellite Systems and Control

Publication details

Journal / source
EKONOMIKA I UPRAVLENIE PROBLEMY RESHENIYA
Volume
1/11
Issue
166
Pages
128–137
Publication date
1 January 2026
Language
EN