The Relationship Between the Categories of “Independence”, “Impartiality”, “Objectivity” and “Fairness” in Criminal Proceedings

View at publisher Summarise with VIRAT
Authors: Alexander V. Petrov
Cited by: 0

Summary

No summary yet. VIRAT can read this paper and write a plain-language summary of its aim, methods, key findings and limitations.

Summarise with VIRAT Free to try with your Science Catalogs account.

Abstract

The fundamental categories of ultimate generality, independence, impartiality, objectivity and fairness in criminal proceedings have their own content and common areas where these categories intersect. Clarification of the content of these categories, their relationship with each other and highlighting the common in their content is important for law enforcement practice in the process of resolving criminal cases and materials. The purpose of the study is the need to outline the content of these categories and determine the “fields” of their intersection. For this purpose, these categories were analyzed in the interpretation of Russian scientists, in international legal acts and international bodies when considering individual communications, as well as the interpretation of Russian criminal procedure legislation and law enforcement practice. The comparative legal methods were applied, with the help of which the conclusion was made about the coincidence of interpretations of independence and impartiality in international legal documents and Russian legislation and law enforcement practice; about different interpretations of the category of “justice” in criminal proceedings and the absence in international legal documents and Russian legislation of the category of objectivity, which can be attributed to scientific categories and categories of law enforcement practice. With the help of analysis, the internal content of each of the categories and their intersection with each other were determined, the generalization method made it possible to identify the common in these categories and their relationship with each other. Conclusions were made about the content of each of the categories and their relationship with each other. Independence (objective, external) relates to a greater extent to the judicial system and ensures the independence of the judicial system from the influence of bodies and officials of other branches of government. Independence of judges (internal) implies the absence of influence on judges within the judicial system and from the parties. Impartiality characterizes the internal independence of the judge’s personality. These categories are the foundations of fair criminal proceedings, are the characteristics of the judicial system, courts and judges. Fairness and objectivity are the characteristics of the process of consideration and resolution of criminal cases and its outcome.

Fields of Study & Subjects

Legal processes and jurisprudence Criminal Law and Policy Criminal Law and Evidence

Publication details

Journal / source
Rossijskoe pravosudie
Issue
3
Pages
104–112
Publication date
10 March 2026
Language
EN