Stormwater management and heat mitigation performance of blue-green infrastructure in a current and future climate

Read full text Summarise with VIRAT
Authors: Giovan Battista Cavadini
Cited by: 0
References: 213

Summary

No summary yet. VIRAT can read this paper and write a plain-language summary of its aim, methods, key findings and limitations.

Summarise with VIRAT Free to try with your Science Catalogs account.

Abstract

Blue-Green Infrastructure (BGI), which include landscape elements such as bioretention cells, green roofs, and ponds, have been increasingly implemented in urban areas to mitigate the negative environmental impacts of urbanization and to adapt to climate change. By enhancing infiltration and stormwater retention, BGI can reduce Combined Sewer Overflows (CSOs), while simultaneously mitigating urban heat through evaporative cooling and shading. Although BGI are often described as multifunctional, their potential to manage stormwater and to mitigate heat has rarely been evaluated within a unified framework. Typically, BGI elements are assessed individually and with respect to a single objective: most studies focus either on BGI designed for infiltration (e.g., bioretention cells) or on BGI primarily aimed at heat mitigation (e.g., ponds), without accounting for the interdependence of the hydrological and thermal processes that drive these benefits. This siloed approach has limited the understanding of BGI synergies and trade-offs, hindering implementations that simultaneously support CSO reductions and urban heat mitigation. Harnessing these synergies is especially crucial for climate adaptation, given that future climate is projected to bring more intense rainfall and more frequent heat extremes. Yet, despite the growing availability of climate projections, BGI performance under future climatic conditions is still rarely evaluated. This PhD thesis evaluates the CSO reduction and heat mitigation potential of BGI combinations (including bioretention cells, porous pavements, green roofs, and detention ponds) under both current and future climate conditions, using the town of Fehraltorf (Switzerland) as a case study. By applying aligned assumptions and input parameters across hydrodynamic and land surface models, this work provides an integrated assessment that identifies the synergies and trade-offs of different BGI implementations, evaluates their climate adaptation potential, and examines the opportunities and challenges of comparing model outputs across these two disciplines. To evaluate the potential of BGI combinations to reduce CSO volume and frequency, a new methodology was developed in Chapter 2 to generate comprehensive, catchment-wide BGI scenarios. This approach enabled the generation of a set of 60 BGI scenarios that integrated 15 BGI combinations, four implementation rates, and four runoff-routing strategies, which were subsequently simulated using the Stormwater Management Model (SWMM). Results showed that BGI substantially reduced CSO volumes. Bioretention cells provided the largest reductions when they received runoff from upstream areas, achieving reductions comparable to scenarios combining multiple BGI elements. The cost analysis showed that implementing BGI on 10% of the sewer catchment area was the most cost-effective option, as the additional CSO reduction from larger implementation areas did not compensate the higher investment and maintenance costs. Building toward the quantification of the climate adaptation potential of combined BGI, the analysis presented in Chapter 3 quantified the impact of climate change on CSO discharges using four climate models, while assessing how effectively the combined BGI scenarios could reduce these impacts. CSO volumes were projected to increase across all climate models, however, changes in CSO frequency varied depending on the model. Although all BGI combinations partially reduced climate change impacts on CSOs, only four specific configurations that included bioretention cells could fully prevent the projected rise in both CSO volume and frequency, regardless implementation rate and climate model. Additionally, BGI were found to be more cost-effective under future climate, as they were projected to infiltrate and retain more water in a climate with more intense rainfall events. To extend the analysis to heat mitigation, the land surface model Urban Tethys–Chloris (UT&C) was adapted to explicitly represent detention ponds and runoff routing. As presented in Chapter 4, the BGI elements previously evaluated for CSO reduction can also provide heat mitigation up to 2.7 °C. However, the magnitude of this cooling depended on the BGI element, the type of surface it replaced, and whether water was available for evapotranspiration. Importantly, a design trade-off for bioretention cells was revealed. Bioretention cells with sandy soils enhanced infiltration and thus supported runoff reduction (stormwater mitigation), whereas clay-rich soils retained more moisture and thereby promoted greater evaporative cooling (heat mitigation). Overall, climate change did not substantially diminish the heat mitigation potential of BGI; however, the prolonged dry periods projected under future climate conditions could markedly reduce the evaporative cooling provided by vegetated BGI. Moving toward an integrated assessment of BGI, Chapter 5 compared the results from previous chapters to identify synergies, trade-offs, and the combined climate adaptation potential of BGI. Overall, CSO reduction and heat mitigation objectives were largely synergistic, but important trade-offs emerged. In bioretention cells, sandy soils favored infiltration, while clay-rich soils enhanced evaporative cooling. Detention ponds, although effective at lowering CSO volumes and providing strong daytime cooling, could increase CSO frequency and nighttime temperatures. These findings highlighted that BGI implementation cannot rely on a single “optimal” solution: competing objectives must be balanced, or one objective prioritized according to site-specific needs. While all BGI elements contributed to climate adaptation, only bioretention cells effectively prevented the projected increase in CSOs, and no single element could offset the anticipated rise in temperature. In conclusion, these findings demonstrated that the optimal BGI implementation depends strongly on the primary design objective. Bioretention cells were the most effective for reducing CSOs, whereas detention ponds provided the greatest cooling during heat stress periods. By integrating hydrodynamic and land surface modeling approaches, this work provided a replicable framework to support urban planners in selecting BGI strategies that balance hydrological and thermal objectives. Overall, this thesis advanced the quantification of multi-objective BGI benefits, clarified where synergies and trade-offs arise, and contributed to more holistic and climate-robust decision-making at the urban catchment scale.

Fields of Study & Subjects

Urban Stormwater Management Solutions Urban Heat Island Mitigation Land Use and Ecosystem Services

Publication details

Journal / source
DORA Eawag (Swiss Federal Institute of Aquatic Science and Technology (Eawag))
Publication date
1 January 2026
Language
EN
Document type
Thesis