The Social Security Reform Con

View at publisher Summarise with VIRAT
Authors: Maya Rockeymoore Cummings
Cited by: 0

Summary

No summary yet. VIRAT can read this paper and write a plain-language summary of its aim, methods, key findings and limitations.

Summarise with VIRAT Free to try with your Science Catalogs account.

Abstract

In 2005, President George W. Bush declared his first policy priority following reelection would be the privatization of Social Security. To justify the proposal, he pointed to an African American man on seated on a White House panel, arguing that Social Security was unfair to Black men because of differences in life expectancy and lifetime earnings. It was a striking maneuver. A political party that had shown little sustained commitment to addressing persistent challenges facing Black men suddenly claimed to be acting in their interest- -by dismantling the nation's most important social insurance program. The conservative strategy was clear: weaponize disparities rooted in structural racism to weaken support for Social Security itself. I had been preparing for this moment for years. In 1999, I joined the Social Security subcommittee of the US House Committee on Ways and Means. The subcommittee's staff director, Sandy Wise, had noticed conservative think tanks developing arguments claiming that Social Security disadvantaged African Americans. She hired me—fresh from a Congressional Black Caucus Foundation Fellowship—to analyze their claims, develop counterarguments, educate members of Congress, and build a coalition of researchers and advocates to protect Social Security. Even after I left Capitol Hill, my professional path kept circling back to Social Security. After managing Congressman Charles Rangel's office and completing my dissertation, I became a Senior Resident Scholar for Health and Income Security at the National Urban League. There, I wrote extensively about Social Security's importance to African Americans and the dangers of privatization for women and other vulnerable groups. To stay closely connected to allied policy communities, I joined the National Academy of Social Insurance and served onthe boards of the National Committee to Preserve Social Security and Medicare and the National Council on Aging. I also helped convene an independent Social Security modernization commission that brought together stakeholders from vulnerable communities. Our group developed a set of reform proposals that diverged sharply from those advanced by the presidents’ formal commissions. At times, I found myself wondering why I was being drawn so deeply into the technical and political minutiae of the program, even though I understood how vital it was to my own family and to millions of Americans. Bush's reelection made the answer unmistakeable. As Vice President of Research and Programs at the Congressional Black Caucus Foundation, I mobilized immediately. Through its Center for Policy Analysis and Research- -a policy shot I established at CBCF- -our research team produced fact sheets, briefs, and talking points for members of Congress and allied organizations. I moved between Capitol Hill, union halls, civil rights groups, women's organizations, sororities and fraternities, and community-based meetings across the country, explaning why privatization threatened targeted groups and the economic security of millions. Helping to defeat President Bush's proposal remains one of my proudest professional accomplishments but the battle revealed something deeper: the details of policy debates are fertile ground for rageism. The structure of policy proposals- -how benefits are calculated, who bears risk, and which groups are positioned as worthy or undeserving- -determines whether Social Security (as well as other programs and policies) functions as a fairly shared obligation or as a vehicle for wealth extraction. This chapter examines the Social Security reform proposals advanced under Presidents George W. Bush and Barack Obama, with particular attention to how they would have affected vulnerable groups, including communities of color. It shows how ostensibly neutral policy design can systematically advantage white and male wealth while undermining the economic security of everyone else- -and why the fight over Social Security is ultimately a fight over who gets to age with dignity in the United States.

Fields of Study & Subjects

Social Policy and Reform Studies Retirement Disability and Employment Social Issues and Policies

Publication details

Journal / source
Routledge eBooks
Pages
349–386
Publication date
25 March 2026
Language
EN
Document type
Book chapter