Arius in Modern Research
Summary
No summary yet. VIRAT can read this paper and write a plain-language summary of its aim, methods, key findings and limitations.
Summarise with VIRAT Free to try with your Science Catalogs account.Abstract
there is no need to argue the crucial importance of the Arian controversy in the early development of Christian doctrine, and much new light has been thrown on its history in recent years. Yet the motives and intentions of Arius himself are still disputed. I have taken the opportunity to reconsider them in a fairly nontechnical style, reproducing a lecture generously commissioned by the University of Mainz. I shall consider three subjects: our evidence for Arius’ doctrine; the main intention of his theology; and his relation to earlier thinkers. I will make some introductory remarks on each of these points. Arius’ writings have not survived in extenso. Our knowledge of his thought depends on three sources. We have letters written by Arius, which differ notably in their occasion and their emphasis. The earliest, Optiz Urkunde i, is a short note written to an influential friend, in which Arius complains that he has been unjustly treated by his bishop, Alexander, and sets out some points of disagreement. The next, Urkunde 6, is a respectful approach to Alexander in which Arius explains his theology in more accommodating terms, apparently in the hope of securing toleration. The third, Urkunde 30, is a short credal statement addressed to the Emperor Constantine, which avoids all controversial points. The first two letters were written c.320 A.D., the third, I believe, c.333; 1 it resulted, of course, in the Emperor’s withdrawing the condemnation imposed on Arius by the Council of Nicaea. A few phrases from a fourth letter are quoted by Constantine; see Opitz Urkunde 34. We have some remains of the Thalia, a composition in verse in which Arius presents his theology in forcible terms. The first seven lines are quoted by Athanasius in his ‘First Oration against the Arians’, published perhaps C.340A.D., some twenty years after the poem was written. Twenty years later again Athanasius quoted some forty-two lines in his work De Synodis, along with other Arian documents. This, I believe, is valuable evidence. There is a great mass of material in the form of reports and criticisms of Arius’ doctrine by Alexander and especially by Athanasius. It includes two letters written in the name of Alexander and numerous summaries by Athanasius, all phrased in roughly similar terms. The most influential of these has been the report, based on the Thalia, which Athanasius presents in his ‘First Oration’, chapters 5 and 6. Not all of this report is reliable. It includes quotations, or alleged quotations, from the writings of Arius and of his colleague Asterius. But these are interspersed with hostile comments, and we also hear of remarks thrown off in conversation by unnamed Arian partisans. Scholars in the past have been far too ready to treat all this evidence as equally valid. In particular, they have preferred the indirect evidence of Athanasius to probable quotations from Arius, who is a heretic. Arius’ chief theological interest, it has long been supposed, was to uphold the unique dignity of God the Father, especially in comparison with the divine Logos. Alexandrian theology at this time was pluralist; it insisted that the Second and Third Persons of the Trinity were real and substantial beings, and not mere energies or functions of the Father. Alexander followed Origen in holding that the Logos was eternally generated from the Father; he differed from Origen in ascribing to him equal dignity and power. Arius rejected both these doctrines. To make the Logos coeternal and equally divine, he thought, was to preach two Gods; the Logos must be seen as junior, as radically inferior and subordinate to the Father. This view is strongly expressed in Arius’ first letter and in the Thalia fragments. Nevertheless Arius expresses this doctrine within certain limitations. He describes the Logos, in Isaiah’s words, as ‘a mighty God’. Although junior to the Father, and created by him, the Logos was called into being before all creation and executed the Father’s creative work. So much is repeatedly disclosed by Athanasius. But Arius appears to have been inconsistent. He emphasized the lesser dignity of the Logos by pointing to human limitations which he underwent as incarnate in Jesus: suffering, uncertainty, the need for decision, and the like. 2 It might seem that a Logos who was, next to the Father, the supreme architect of the universe should eo ipso be wise and powerful and proof against human weakness. Nevertheless Arius, or some of his followers, described the Logos as, in important respects, subject to our infirmities; the opposing party seized on these admissions, and complained that he considered the Logos a mere man, no more than a man. It was this side of Arius’ doctrine that was taken up by two American scholars, Robert Gregg and Dennis Groh. 3 In their view the main concern of Arius was not to subordinate the Logos to the Father, but to offer a distinctive approach to salvation. The Arian Logos, they think, is conceived as a morally perfect man, subject to our human limitations, and showing us by his example how those limitations can be overcome. This view has met with some criticism; but it has been given a cautious welcome by Dr Rudolf Lorenz. He has expressed it in the pregnant phrase ‘Arius ist Isochrist’. 4 He does not mean, of course, that Arius was the equal of Christ; nor indeed that he claimed to be so. He means that, in Arius’ view, men are capable of attaining equality with Christ; and this entails, conversely, that Arius assigns no greater dignity to Christ than a perfect man could attain. Lorenz agrees with Gregg and Groh that Arius’ main interest lies in Christology; and he seems to accept their view that Arius’ Christology is an adoptionist one, ‘ adoptianistisch’ . 5 These points are associated with a distinctive view of Arius’ antecedents. Lorenz holds that Arius’ doctrine of the Logos is influenced by Origen’s teaching on the soul of Christ, rather than by Origen’s Logos doctrine itself. Furthermore, he believes that Arius stands in a line of tradition which derives from Paul of Samosata. 6 Both these suppositions lend support to the view that Arius teaches an adoptionist Christology.
Fields of Study & Subjects
Augustinian Studies and Theology
Biblical Studies and Interpretation
Byzantine Studies and History
Publication details
- Journal / source
- Routledge eBooks
- Pages
- IV–24
- Publication date
- 2 February 2026
- Language
- EN
- Document type
- Book chapter