The Existing Distribution of Raw Materials

View at publisher Summarise with VIRAT
Authors: Herman Kranold
Cited by: 0

Summary

No summary yet. VIRAT can read this paper and write a plain-language summary of its aim, methods, key findings and limitations.

Summarise with VIRAT Free to try with your Science Catalogs account.

Abstract

WE now begin to formulate explicitly the result of the masses of figures we have marshalled in our statistical tables. But before doing so I have to explain the methods on which the last table of our Appendix is based, and to deduce the inferences to which it leads. My endeavour was to try to find out if it is possible, with some real meaning, to measure the strength of the more important countries in terms of a series of comprehensive figures. Of course the argument can be raised that to do this is arbitrary and is, at the same time, something like adding up apples and pigs. All that is quite true, just as it is true that an examiner, by giving marks, inevitably violates realities to some extent, and that giving marks often enough means a wild, though respectable orgy of individualism. But in spite of all these well-founded doubts examinations will continue to be useful; and as in politics the classification of nations under the heads of “Haves” and “Have-Nots” will be used again and again, it seemed worth while trying to bring at least some small amount of method and consistence into the study of these international problems. So I have worked out the following system of giving marks: For every one of the raw materials 10 marks were shared among the countries producing it, whether the country was mentioned in our table or not; the proportion of the 10 marks obtained by each producing country was equal to the proportion of the world supply of the raw material in question which the particular country contributed, so that a country contributing 10 per cent. of the world supply received I mark, etc. I avoided decimals and rounded off the figures to the next integer, according to the usual system, seeing to it, however, that no vertical column in the table ever showed a sum higher than 10. In so far as these marks fell to one of the 15 countries appearing in this table these marks were credited to them in Table A. Marks falling to countries not included in this table simply dropped out of our calculation, so that the sum of one vertical column may be (and very often is) less than io, and may even be zero. Colonial resources were included in the wealth of the mother country. In the case of the U.K., the Dominions and India were treated as separate countries, so that “Great Britain” in this table means: England and Wales, Scotland, Northern Ireland, the Crown Colonies, Protectorates and Mandated Territories. Burma was treated as part of India; so were the territories of the Indian Princes. The Anglo-Egyptian Sudan was treated as a British colony. In the case of Italy, Ethiopia reckons as a colony (though that has scarcely any importance for our table), and in the case of Japan, Manchuria is treated as part of the Japanese Empire, just like Formosa, Korea, etc. The Philippine Islands are treated as a separate entity, not as colonies of the United States. This was the simpler part of the whole plan. The more difficult one was the process of weighting these marks. This was and is a very doubtful affair. The weighting of some raw materials depends entirely on whether a country is at peace or at war. Strontium is, only in peace-time, e.g., important for fireworks for amusement purposes. This is so extremely sub-ordinate a purpose that we would not have included this metal in our inquiry at all for this sake; the same is true in regard to the use of strontium compounds in the cane-sugar industry. But in war-time strontium compounds may be very important, as they were from 1914 to 1918, because the strong red light which they produce when they are burned makes them a very valuable raw material for signalling-rockets. That is why we have included strontium in our inquiry and our table. But should peace-time or war-time importance serve as the basis of weighting? After much hesitation I decided on the following system of weighting, the results of which I give for what they may seem worth to my readers—I feel very far from being cocksure in regard to this method. I found out, as nearly as possible, what proportion of the total value of world exports the value of the known exports of the material in question formed. This was expressed as a “weighting index” for that product, expressed in thousandth-parts of total world trade. In those cases where it was not possible to find such a figure (they are all cases of “minor” materials) one -thousandth was taken. The number of thousandths falling to every raw material in this way has been entered in the Appendix, in Table E, B in the form of integers. Part C of Table E contains the results obtained by multi-plying the figures of Table A by the weighting indexes of Table B, and of adding up the horizontal lines of Table C. For obvious reasons iron ore, iron and steel were treated as separate items. This seemed to me the best way of evading the difficulty arising from the impossibility of obtaining figures showing the importance of scrap iron in the individual countries. For other metals the problem of scrap did not seem to me of sufficient importance to take particular notice of it in the weighting system. In the case of gold, however, where “ scrap “ is identical, more or less, with the gold imprisoned in the cellars of the banks, gold in banks and gold production were treated as separate items, the same weighting figure being taken for both. 1

Fields of Study & Subjects

World Systems and Global Transformations Natural Resources and Economic Development Global trade and economics

Publication details

Journal / source
Routledge eBooks
Pages
99–141
Publication date
25 March 2026
Language
EN
Document type
Book chapter