Unreliable science in the courtroom: shifting the courts’ focus from assessing the substance of an expert's analysis to the process by which it was produced

Read full text Summarise with VIRAT
Authors: Wendy E Wagner
Cited by: 0

Summary

No summary yet. VIRAT can read this paper and write a plain-language summary of its aim, methods, key findings and limitations.

Summarise with VIRAT Free to try with your Science Catalogs account.

Abstract

Judges are tasked with safeguarding the reliability of scientific expert evidence-a responsibility complicated by the lack of in-house expertise and resources in the judiciary. Despite these constraints, courts must act as arbiters of scientific integrity, whether weighing evidence in litigation or reviewing agency science under the APA. This chapter critically examines how courts approach this challenge, comparing current judicial practices with the scientific community’s standards for reliability. While courts gravitate toward assessing the substantive accuracy of scientific claims, they frequently overlook process integrity—key factors like research independence, clear attribution, and rigorous peer review—that form the backbone of trustworthy science. To address this gap, the chapter proposes a pragmatic recalibration: integrating process-based disclosures into judicial oversight. By encouraging parties to voluntarily submit standardized information on the rigor of their scientific process during litigation, courts can move beyond merely adjudicating battles of the experts and begin to critically assess the integrity of the scientific evidence itself. Although these disclosures cannot resolve every challenge at the intersection of law and science, they offer a practical step forward—providing courts with greater insight into scientific reliability and promising meaningful improvements over current practices, with minimal disruption.

Fields of Study & Subjects

Legal processes and jurisprudence Law Economics and Judicial Systems Education and Society

Publication details

Journal / source
Edward Elgar Publishing eBooks
Pages
169–212
Publication date
19 March 2026
Language
EN
Document type
Book chapter