Implicit Intelligence -- Evaluating Agents on What Users Don't Say

Read full text
Authors: Ved Sirdeshmukh, Marc Wetter
Cited by: 0

Abstract

Real-world requests to AI agents are fundamentally underspecified. Natural human communication relies on shared context and unstated constraints that speakers expect listeners to infer. Current agentic benchmarks test explicit instruction-following but fail to evaluate whether agents can reason about implicit requirements spanning accessibility needs, privacy boundaries, catastrophic risks, and contextual constraints. We present Implicit Intelligence, an evaluation framework testing whether AI agents can move beyond prompt-following to become genuine goal-fulfillers, paired with Agent-as-a-World (AaW), a harness where interactive worlds are defined in human-readable YAML files and simulated by language models. Our scenarios feature apparent simplicity in user requests, hidden complexity in correct solutions, and discoverability of constraints through environmental exploration. Evaluating 16 frontier and open-weight models across 205 scenarios, we find that even the best-performing model achieves only 48.3% scenario pass rate, revealing substantial room for improvement in bridging the gap between literal instruction-following and human-like contextual reasoning.

Fields of Study & Subjects

Speech and dialogue systems Natural Language Processing Techniques AI-based Problem Solving and Planning

Publication details

Journal / source
arXiv (Cornell University)
Publication date
23 February 2026
Language
EN
Document type
Preprint