THEMIS: Towards Holistic Evaluation of MLLMs for Scientific Paper Fraud Forensics

Read full text Summarise with VIRAT
Authors: Tzu-Yen Ma, Bo Zhang, Zichen Tang, Junpeng Ding, Haolin Tian, Yuanze Li, Zhuodi Hao, Zixin Ding, Zirui Wang, Xinyu Yu, Shiyao Peng, Yizhuo Zhao
+11 more Ruomeng Jiang, Yiling Huang, Peizhi Zhao, Jiayuan Chen, Weisheng Tan, Haocheng Gao, Yang Liu, Jiacheng Liu, Zhongjun Yang, Jiayu Huang, Haihong E
Cited by: 0
References: 24

Summary

No summary yet. VIRAT can read this paper and write a plain-language summary of its aim, methods, key findings and limitations.

Summarise with VIRAT Free to try with your Science Catalogs account.

Abstract

We present THEMIS, a novel multi-task benchmark designed to comprehensively evaluate multimodal large language models (MLLMs) on visual fraud reasoning within real-world academic scenarios. Compared to existing benchmarks, THEMIS introduces three major advances. (1) Real-World Scenarios and Complexity: Our benchmark comprises over 4,000 questions spanning seven scenarios, derived from authentic retracted-paper cases and carefully curated multimodal synthetic data. With 60.47% complex-texture images, THEMIS bridges the critical gap between existing benchmarks and the complexity of real-world academic fraud. (2) Fraud-Type Diversity and Granularity: THEMIS systematically covers five challenging fraud types and introduces 16 fine-grained manipulation operations. On average, each sample undergoes multiple stacked manipulation operations, with the diversity and difficulty of these manipulations demanding a high level of visual fraud reasoning from the models. (3) Multi-Dimensional Capability Evaluation: We establish a mapping from fraud types to five core visual fraud reasoning capabilities, thereby enabling an evaluation that reveals the distinct strengths and specific weaknesses of different models across these core capabilities. Experiments on 16 leading MLLMs show that even the best-performing model, GPT-5, achieves an overall performance of only 56.15%, demonstrating that our benchmark presents a stringent test. We expect THEMIS to advance the development of MLLMs for complex, real-world fraud reasoning tasks.

Fields of Study & Subjects

Digital Media Forensic Detection Academic integrity and plagiarism Multimodal Machine Learning Applications

Publication details

Journal / source
arXiv (Cornell University)
Publication date
26 March 2026
Language
EN
Document type
Preprint