Comment on egusphere-2025-4233

Abstract. Riming and aggregation are critical ice-phase microphysical processes in winter clouds, but their overlapping signatures and dynamic transitions pose challenges for conventional single-frequency radar detection. We introduce a novel gradient-based identification method using ground-based triple-frequency dual-polarization radar observations. By analyzing vertical gradients of triple-frequency radar variables, rather than their absolute values, we discern these microphysical processes through physically based thresholds that reflect particle growth regimes. This approach captures subtle spatiotemporal variations in riming and aggregation that conventional threshold methods would miss, particularly in resolving layered riming-aggregation transitions. The dynamic gradient-based method demonstrates the enhanced physical consistency and adaptability near process boundaries, which obviously improve the tracking of ice-particle evolution. These advances provide a pathway to refine microphysical parameterizations and enhance high-resolution snowfall forecasting.