Comment on egusphere-2025-6339

Abstract. Iron (Fe) availability modulates phytoplankton blooms in High-Nutrient Low-Chlorophyll (HNLC) regions, i.e., ocean areas characterized by an abundance of major nutrients but low marine productivity. Fe can be delivered to the oceans through atmospheric dust deposition, making ice cores unique archives for reconstructing past changes in aeolian Fe deposition. However, while it is known that during dustier periods atmospheric Fe depositions increased, uncertainties remain regarding the fraction of Fe actually available to phytoplankton. Here, we present evidence from the EGRIP ice core (Greenland), which allows insights into atmospheric aerosol deposition over the Fe-limited North Pacific Ocean, during the Pleistocene-Holocene transition (10.3–13.0 ka). Results show that, in contrast to the 17-fold enhancement in total Fe concentration, dissolved Fe increased only modestly (+29 %) during the Younger Dryas compared to the Early Holocene, likely due to prevailing alkaline aerosol conditions reducing its solubility. This finding supports the hypothesis that factors other than atmospheric Fe deposition (e.g., stronger water stratification, sea-ice extent, volcanic eruptions, iron remobilization from sediments), play a more relevant role in regulating marine net primary productivity in the HNLC North Pacific Ocean over the last glacial transition.