Comment on essd-2025-654

Abstract. Nutrients play a critical role in oceanic primary productivity and the biological pump. However, compared to hydrographic parameters such as temperature and salinity, nutrient observations are limited due to their labor-intensive and costly measurements. Thus, nutrient observations are several orders of magnitude sparser than hydrographic observations. In this study, we first established a rigorous data quality control procedure to clean the hydrographic and nutrient (including NO₃⁻, NO₂⁻, DIP, and Si(OH)₄) observations collected from World Ocean Database (WOD) and CLIVAR and Carbon Hydrographic Data Office (CCHDO) in the North Pacific. Subsequently, the cleaned and high-quality CCHDO dataset was used to train three machine learning models – Random Forest, Light Gradient Boosting Machine (LightGBM), and Gaussian Process Regression – to establish relationships between nutrient concentrations and key variables, including space coordinates (longitude, latitude, and depth), time variables (year and month), and water mass properties (indexed by potential temperature and salinity). Validation shows that the reconstruction closely matches the observations, with RMSEs of