A UVLM Peer Review of : An Informational Projection Constraint on Observable State Spaces

Reviewer Context & Competing Interest: This review is written with awareness of the reviewer’s own prior work (Prislac/UVLM framework) that uses a micro-state space Φ, defines coarse-grained observables, and includes an information-loss term in a total action formalism. While the present manuscript shares a similar form (a deep state space projected to observables with information loss), the reviewer emphasizes that conceptual similarity alone does not imply copying. No direct textual overlap or reuse of unique constructs has been detected. The critique below focuses on scientific clarity and originality, not on penalizing parallel ideas.