tz-dev/PMS-CRITIQUE: PMS–CRITIQUE v1.0 — From Irritation to Correction: A Praxeological Grammar of Critique (Δ–Ψ)
Abstract
PMS–CRITIQUE is a formal, operator-strict application of the Praxeological Meta-Structure (PMS, Δ–Ψ) to the phenomenon of critique. The project reconstructs critique not as an attitude, virtue, or discourse norm, but as a structurally constrained form of praxis: a χ-stabilized interruption that can mutate under load when integration (Σ) or self-binding (Ψ) fail. This release introduces: a strict minimal definition of critique as interruptible framed differentiation (Δ under □ with Χ), a drift typology showing how critique predictably mutates into reaction, judgment, narrative reset, silence, or exposure, a horizontal scale model (a–d) explaining why the same critique grammar behaves differently under self, group, and public exposure, explicit treatment of non-event load (Λ), asymmetry (Ω), and temporality (Θ) as cost-shaping forces, and a curated Example Suite of five scene-bound, operator-legible cases that stress-test critique under real conditions. The project is fully PMS_1.1-conform: no new operators are introduced, no dependencies are violated, all analyses remain scene-bound, reversible, and non-diagnostic, and all applications are guarded by the PMS entry condition: Χ (distance) + reversibility + D (dignity-in-practice). PMS–CRITIQUE does not evaluate speakers, rank positions, or prescribe outcomes. It provides a structural grammar for understanding why critique so often fails even when intentions are good — and why expression alone is not correction. Canonical contents included in this release: Full paper (Markdown, HTML, PDF) Five structurally uniform critique examples (Markdown + HTML) Operator-strict drift and scale models CSS and figures for standalone publication Critique begins where a mismatch becomes interruptible — correction begins where interruption is integrated and bound.
Fields of Study & Subjects
Pragmatism in Philosophy and Education
Embodied and Extended Cognition
Emotions and Moral Behavior
Publication details
- Journal / source
- Zenodo (CERN European Organization for Nuclear Research)
- Publication date
- 7 January 2026