Causation, Agency, and Existence: Historical Control and Maintained Intervention

Read full text
Authors: Sidong Liu
Cited by: 0

Abstract

A cause changes what an allowed intervention can bring about; a record alone need not identify that change. We define interventional influence relative to a process, an intervention set and a readout. It contracts under post-processing and along channel chains. A direct cause and a common cause can have identical declared record laws and influences \(1\) and \(0\). Agency requires more than a persistent register. In a binary tracking task, the memoryless failure probability is bounded by \(\frac12[1-(1-2q)\kappa_{\mathrm s}\kappa_{\mathrm c}]\). Three retained readings beat every present-reading controller in the specified sensor menu, despite a smaller influence of the present world on the action. We then give the same agent a damageable body: an actual mixed-port diagnosis controls repair, and the repaired body determines the next sensing channel. The finite reversible protocol maintains tracking error at most \(0.15820\) from a healthy start, against a long-run lower bound \(0.22172\) for damage-independent maintenance calendars at the same repair rate. All spent ports and old records remain; fresh blank supply is not a thermal reset. This is a mechanism for maintaining intervention capability, not a derivation of the initial body or its couplings. These results support relational existence: structures can be objective within their coupling, history and observation window without being intrinsic to a state alone. The essay develops implications for will, self-maintenance and structural realism, then compares traces and dependence with Yogācāra and Mādhyamaka. These comparisons have their own arguments and do not establish phenomenal consciousness.

Fields of Study & Subjects

Critical Realism in Sociology Philosophy and History of Science Qualitative Comparative Analysis Research

Publication details

Journal / source
Zenodo (CERN European Organization for Nuclear Research)
Publication date
26 January 2026
Document type
Preprint