ODP Standard v3.6 (Pre-Pilot Draft): Overclaim · Dismissal · Precision

ODP (Overclaim–Dismissal–Precision) is a candidate protocol for epistemic QA of scientific and technical claims. It standardizes claim extraction, proportionality checks between claims and evidence (overclaim), identification of research-blocking rhetoric in the presence of signal (dismissal), and enforced rewriting into precision-claims (metric, procedure, falsifier, baseline). The protocol includes a Risk Index (RI), priority statuses (NON-OP / MIXED / INCONCLUSIVE), and an inter-rater reliability (IRR) gate intended to move the standard from “pre-pilot draft” to a validated, community-usable protocol. This record contains two companion artifacts:(1) ODP Standard Pre-Pilot v3.6 (PDF + LaTeX source)(2) How to Run Pilot-0 (Quick Start) (PDF + LaTeX source) Pre-Pilot disclaimer: v3.6 is released before Pilot-0 to invite feedback on rubrics, weights, examples, and tooling. Planned steps include Pilot-0 (~50 works, 300–500 claims), Checkpoint-20 calibration, IRR-1, and a public Casebank release, after which the protocol will be updated. Repository/tooling link: to be added in the first post-release update (v1.0.1) or via the project homepage once published.See ‘Related works’ on this record for the series spine and companion case studies.