Boundary Condition Robustness as a Necessary Condition for Standing

Read full text
Authors: Amos Maley
Cited by: 0

Abstract

This paper shows that if epistemic standing is to be preserved under admissible variation of boundary conditions, then robustness of those boundary conditions is a necessary requirement. When boundary specifications are permitted to change within an admissible range, any dependence of standing on finely tuned or fragile boundary choices leads to representational instability. In such cases, small admissible perturbations produce discontinuous failures of standing, indicating that the boundary conditions themselves are not admissibly licensed. The result is conditional and eliminative. It does not assert which boundary conditions must be imposed, nor does it propose a mechanism for enforcing robustness. Instead, it establishes that boundary conditions which fail to remain stable under admissible variation cannot support standing. Any description whose validity depends on boundary sensitivity is therefore excluded as standing-preserving, independently of the underlying domain or interpretive context.

Fields of Study & Subjects

Epistemology Ethics and Metaphysics Philosophy and History of Science Philosophy Science and History

Publication details

Journal / source
Zenodo (CERN European Organization for Nuclear Research)
Publication date
5 February 2026