B8 Authority Based Legitimacy Is Impossible

Read full text
Authors: Amos Maley
Cited by: 0

Abstract

This paper establishes an impossibility result for authority-based legitimacy within a closed admissible framework. It proves that legitimacy cannot be grounded in institutional position, delegated power, expert status, or hierarchical authority without violating admissibility or standing conservation. Any appeal to authority is shown to introduce external authorization, deferred validation, or illicit scope transport, collapsing admissibility. The analysis is strictly eliminative and non-constructive: it introduces no new primitives, specifies no procedures, and provides no operational or enforcement criteria. The result functions as a boundary theorem, ruling out authority as an admissible foundation for legitimacy in closed systems.

Fields of Study & Subjects

Political Philosophy and Ethics Philosophical Ethics and Theory Access Control and Trust

Publication details

Journal / source
Zenodo (CERN European Organization for Nuclear Research)
Publication date
7 February 2026