What Makes a Thing a Thing? Conditional Stabilization as the Ontological Ground of Object Identity

Read full text
Authors: David (Daoud) Matta
Cited by: 0

Abstract

What is an object, and what allows it to persist through change? Classical philosophy offers divergent answers: Aristotle analyzes objects through categorical determinations such as quality and quantity; Buddhist philosophy emphasizes conditional origination and impermanence; phenomenology treats objects as stable unities of experience; and modern science models systems as dynamically maintained structures. This paper integrates these traditions into a unified ontological framework in which objects are understood as conditionally stabilized unities. An object is defined as a substance (οὐσία) determined along multiple axes—including quality (ποιόν), quantity (ποσόν), relation (πρός τι), spatial and temporal location (ποῦ, πότε), configuration (κεῖσθαι), and state (πάθος)—whose existence unfolds through three fundamental processes: genesis (γένεσις), transformation (μεταβολή), and dissolution (φθορά). Crucially, these processes are governed by causes (αἰτία) operating under enabling conditions (συνθήκη). This framework reconceives object identity not as static essence but as conditional invariance across structured transformations. By unifying categorical determination, causal conditionality, and dynamical persistence, the proposed model offers a cross-tradition ontology capable of explaining object identity across physical, cognitive, and phenomenological domains.

Fields of Study & Subjects

Classical Philosophy and Thought Philosophy and Theoretical Science Phenomenology and Existential Philosophy

Publication details

Journal / source
PhilPapers (PhilPapers Foundation)
Publication date
17 February 2026
Language
EN