Supplementary Data Toward an AI-Enhanced Relational–Mechanistic Framework for ELT: A CIMO-Based Evidence Synthesis of Ecosystemic Governance in Open and Distributed Learning
Abstract
This repository contains the complete supplementary materials (SM01–SM06) supporting the systematic review titled “Toward an AI-Enhanced Relational–Mechanistic Framework for ELT: A CIMO-Based Evidence Synthesis of Ecosystemic Governance in Open and Distributed Learning and version 2.0 Title: Configurational Rupture and Ecosystemic Governance: An Integrated CIMO-Based Framework for AI-Enhanced ELT"” The dataset includes full inclusion–exclusion protocols, quality appraisal matrices (JBI, MMAT, AMSTAR-2), hybrid thematic coding framework, complete CIMO mapping matrix for 111 empirical studies (2015–2025), cross-level governance synthesis matrices, and negative case analysis with governance failure typology. All materials are provided to ensure methodological transparency, intercoder reliability verification (κ ≥ 0.80), configurational replication, and secondary analytical reuse. The repository operationalizes open science principles in qualitative evidence synthesis and supports further research on AI-supported ELT integration, ecosystemic governance, and digital justice in open and distributed learning contexts. All online supplementary materials (SM01–SM07) are deposited in the Zenodo repository and include: SM01: Inclusion–Exclusion Criteria and Full Search Strategy SM02: Quality Appraisal Matrices (JBI, MMAT, AMSTAR-2) and Scoring Protocol SM03: Matrix Quality Assessment + Relevance to RQ SM04: Matrix Hybrid Thematic + CIMO Mapping SM05: Matrix Validation & Negative Case Analysis SM06: Matrix Distribution of Themes per CIMO Dimension and Research Question (RQ1–RQ4) SM07: Pedagogical Technology SM08: Governance Pathways SM09: ICGF Framework SM10. References SM11. Source XML Files for Visualizations (draw.io) These materials provide detailed coding protocols, intercoder reliability documentation (κ ≥ 0.80), abstraction procedures, and full configurational mapping across Context–Intervention–Mechanism–Outcome dimensions. In addition, the following appendices are included within the main manuscript file: Appendix A: Governance Failure Architecture and Level-Specific Risk Amplification Patterns Appendix B: Full Configurational Mapping of Propositions Across Contextual Variations Appendix C: Cross-Regional Governance Alignment Matrix Appendix D: Coding Reliability AND CIMO Abstraction Process Appendix E: Conceptual Architecture and Functional Roles of Theoretical Components Appendix F: Proposition-Level Articulations with Full Citations Appendix G: Comparative Analysis of AI-in-Education Frameworks Appendix H: Configurational Gaps and Future Research Agenda Appendix I: Micro-Practices of Teacher Mediation—Operationalizing the "Black Box" Together, the supplementary materials and appendices provide complete methodological transparency, enabling independent verification of analytical procedures and facilitating future configurational replication studies.
Fields of Study & Subjects
Digital Education and Society
Global Educational Policies and Reforms
Artificial Intelligence in Education
Publication details
- Journal / source
- Zenodo (CERN European Organization for Nuclear Research)
- Publication date
- 26 February 2026
- Language
- EN