Artificial vs. Human Intelligence - A Comparative Assessment of Feedback to Data Management Plans

We will compare the AI-generated assessments with those from data support professionals. Comparison of similarities and differences gives an insight into which questions and themes the attention was paid to. Also, we analyse how the reliability and usefulness of AI feedback vary across assessment criteria. This allows us to identify where and why AI aligns or misaligns with expert judgment, informing both tool refinement and context-aware use of AI in research support.