Objectivity as What Survives Translation

Read full text
Authors: Gustaf Ullman
Cited by: 0

Abstract

This note proposes a general framework for metaphysical pluralism modeled on the role of invariance in physics. Let Π be a domain of standpoints (including metaphysical construals) and let S be a codomain of intersubjectively stable structure. A projection p: Π → S maps each standpoint π ∈ Π to its structural residue p(π), understood as what remains stable under admissible cross-standpoint translations (coordination-preserving mappings). The framework has three aims: (i) to characterize objectivity as translation-invariant structure rather than commitment to a privileged metaphysical picture; (ii) to locate phenomenology (qualitative character) on the standpoint side Π rather than as an additional parameter in S; and (iii) to provide an ontological diagnostic for representation-dependent entity talk, illustrated by the role of perturbative bookkeeping devices in quantum field theory. A minimal formal backbone is given by treating reversible admissible translations as a groupoid and by making explicit that p factors through the orbit space Π/∼. The note is compatible with, but does not require, an epistemic structural realist reading; it also accommodates non-reversible coordination relations (e.g. coarse-graining) by moving from groupoids to categories. A schematic non-physical example (presentism vs. eternalism) is included to clarify the intended separation between standpoint-level commitments (Π) and translation-invariant coordination constraints (S). Keywords: objectivity; invariance; metaphysical pluralism; epistemic structural realism; qualia; translations; groupoids; categories; structural residue.

Fields of Study & Subjects

Philosophy and Theoretical Science Epistemology Ethics and Metaphysics Philosophy of Biology and Scientific Explanation

Publication details

Journal / source
Zenodo (CERN European Organization for Nuclear Research)
Publication date
5 March 2026
Language
EN