Abstract
ELSD (Electronic Landscape Stability Diagnostics) v4.0: Correction of a Metalloenzyme VQE Benchmark and an Independently Verified Correlated State for a Zn²⁺ Carbonic Anhydrase II Active-Site Model Supersession notice. This version supersedes v3.0 of this record (10.5281/zenodo.20318424, May 20, 2026) and corrects the ELSD benchmark datasets 10.5281/zenodo.19142883 (v1.0), 10.5281/zenodo.19163956 (v2.0) and 10.5281/zenodo.19212485 (v3.0). The chemistry interpretations in those datasets, and the verdicts in v3.0 of this record, are withdrawn for the reasons given in §3–§4. The original files remain available as a record of what the software produced. Plain Language Summary What we built. Software that simulates the electrons at the metal centers of enzymes that drugs target. It uses a quantum-computing algorithm (the variational quantum eigensolver, VQE), run on a GPU simulator, together with checks meant to tell whether each result can be trusted. What a stricter audit of our published benchmark found. We built a verification process that measures each saved result directly instead of relying on the software's own report. Applied to our earlier published benchmark, it showed that those simulations had stayed at their starting approximation. The differences we had reported between drug targets came from a defect in a penalty term inside the software, not from the chemistry. We traced this to specific defects in the code and corrected them. What the corrected engine does. We ran the corrected engine on a model of the zinc site of carbonic anhydrase II, an enzyme targeted by glaucoma drugs. It captured 74–80% of the extra accuracy available in the model, and 67–76% after keeping only the correct spin state. A second, independently built set of tools reproduced every reported number to ten or more decimal places and identified what is still unfinished: the runs did not fully converge, and part of each result is in the wrong spin state. What this does and does not mean. None of this tells anyone which drug will work. The zinc model was chosen to be small enough that the exact answer can also be computed by conventional means, and that is what makes it a fair test: a quantum method can only be checked where the right answer is already known. On that test, the engine recovered most of the available accuracy on a real metal-enzyme site, and its own safety checks flagged the remaining problems. The next step is to apply it, with the same checks, to problems where the exact answer is out of reach. Why it matters. A computational result can pass its own internal checks and still not measure what it claims to measure. We publish the full verification protocol, the evidence, and the corrected results so that others can check our work and apply the same tests to their own. Abstract We report a forensic re-examination of the ELSD (Electronic Landscape Stability Diagnostics) metalloenzyme benchmark, which used the seed-ensemble spread σ of penalized VQE energies as a measure of electronic-landscape stability for Cu, Zn and Fe active-site models. Evaluating the physical energy of all 110 deposited statevectors (22 systems × 5 seeds) shows that every state is the Hartree–Fock (HF) determinant of its target (N, S_z) sector to within 1.3 × 10⁻⁵ Ha. The published σ values are the seed-to-seed scatter of a constant offset, 3.75–6.25 Ha, introduced by an incompletely expanded S_z penalty. We identify the engine defects responsible, including a "UCCSD-like" double-excitation block that changes particle number and therefore cannot move the state within the target sector. A particle-conserving ansatz (spc) recovers 99.9% of the active-space correlation energy for H₂O/STO-3G and 74–80% (67–76% after singlet projection) for a 20-qubit Zn²⁺ carbonic anhydrase II active-site model. Two independently built toolchains agree on every reported quantity: energies to ≤ 2 × 10⁻¹² Ha and dimensionless quantities to ≤ 1.4 × 10⁻¹¹. We describe the verification protocol, state the limitations of the corrected result, and withdraw the chemistry interpretations of the earlier datasets. Key results [M] Deposited states. All 110 deposited statevectors are the HF determinant of their own (N, S_z) sector (max |E_sector − E_HF| = 1.3 × 10⁻⁵ Ha). The correlation energy available in each active space, 0.03–112 kcal/mol, was not recovered in any of them. [M] What σ measured. Each published σ equals the scatter of a penalty offset λ_sz·(n_orb/8 − t²), not scatter in physical energy. Across seeds, the physical energy varies by at most 4.1 × 10⁻³ kcal/mol. [M] Root causes. Four engine defects (§4) plus four data-handling and provenance issues. The decisive one (D2) is a double-excitation block that changes particle number, which leaves HF a strict local minimum. [M] Corrected method. The particle-conserving spc ansatz (engine v12.1.0 and later) recovers genuine correlation, verified from saved states: H₂O 99.9%, N₂ 56%, and the Zn²⁺ CA-II model 74–80%. [M] Independent verification. The Zn²⁺ result was produced with one AI-agent toolchain and verified by a second, independently built one, with measurements hash-sealed before the producing run's claims were read. All 30 numerical comparisons pass: energies agree to ≤ 2 × 10⁻¹² Ha and dimensionless quantities to ≤ 1.4 × 10⁻¹¹. Labels: [M] = measured and reproducible from the files in this record; [I] = inference. 1. Background and scope 1.1 Records covered Record Version Original claim Status in this version 10.5281/zenodo.19142883 Dataset v1.0 (Mar 2026) 10 locked systems; σ as landscape ruggedness; Cu²⁺ SOD 9.2× apo/bound ratio Interpretations withdrawn; data retained 10.5281/zenodo.19163956 Dataset v2.0 (Mar 2026) 16 locked results; three-part Cu mechanistic decomposition Interpretations withdrawn; data retained 10.5281/zenodo.19212485 Dataset v3.0 (Mar 25, 2026) 25 results; VAP-1 "Nitrogen Rule"; DOTA/NOTA ranking Interpretations withdrawn; data retained This record v3.0 (May 20, 2026) Audit: 12 of 13 systems pass; v1.0 σ reproduces exactly; 9.2× ratio verified Superseded and revised 1.2 How v3.0 of this record is revised v3.0 checked the deposited statevectors against the deposit's own gate criteria (sector cleanliness, dominant-determinant weight dom_p > 0.99, and identical dominant bitstring across seeds) and recomputed σ from the convergence histories. It explicitly left open whether σ reflects physical-energy scatter, pending an in-sector exact reference. This version supplies that reference and the physical-energy measurement, which changes several of v3.0's conclusions: v3.0 section v3.0 statement This version §2.1, §3 12 of 13 systems pass the locked-gate criteria The criteria are satisfied by any single determinant, so they cannot distinguish a converged correlated state from an HF-locked one. All 110 states are HF-locked (§3.1) §2.4 v1.0 σ reproduces exactly from history.csv; v2.0 divergences are a documentation gap The seven v1.0 values were computed from history-tail energies; the v2.0 values used the npz vqe_energy field, which is the deposit's documented recipe (§3.3). Both measure the penalty offset (§3.2) §2.5 The 9.2× Cu²⁺ SOD apo/bound ratio is audit-verified Withdrawn (§3.3, §6) §2.6 Canonical convention is qubit 2i = β The engine source defines α = qubit 2p, β = qubit 2p+1, with qubit 0 as the most significant bit. [I] The v3.0 convention is consistent with reading bitstrings in reversed order, which swaps even and odd positions §3 The geometry-axis and metal-identity decomposition rows survive Withdrawn (§6) §4 Three v1.0 systems unaudited; their values stand Resolved (§3.4) §5 Whether σ reflects physical ruggedness or optimizer behavior is open Answered: σ is penalty-offset scatter (§3.1–§3.2) §5 SCF root stability across rebuilds is untested Tested for Zn_CA2_imidazole: five builds, HF spread 4.5 × 10⁻¹² Ha, same root, internally unstable (§5.2). Not yet tested for the other systems (§8) 2. Methods: verification protocol Each phase of the work followed the same protocol: State-level measurement. The in-sector physical energy ⟨ψ|H|ψ⟩ of each saved statevector is evaluated in float64 from the physical (unpenalized, untruncated) Hamiltonian, together with out-of-sector weight, dominant-determinant weight and, for the Zn²⁺ result, the total-spin decomposition and overlap with the exact ground state. The software's reported energies are compared against these measurements, never used in their place. Exact references. Each system's exact in-sector ground state is computed by sparse Lanczos on the same qubit Hamiltonian, without constructing the full 2²⁰-dimensional operator. Fixtures before data. Every measuring tool passed test cases with known answers before touching real data: 43/43 for the physical-energy auditor, 22/22 spin and sector checks, and 24/24 for the D2 diagnostic bench. When a fixture failed, the tool was corrected, not the test. Byte-level provenance. 385 deposited npz files were matched by SHA-256 to files in the original compute-machine backup (v1: 132, v2: 154, v3: 99), and the engine build that produced them was identified. Fail-closed execution. New runs used no Hamiltonian truncation, no overridden guards and no substituted SCF roots. When a guard tripped, the run stopped and reported what it had established. Separation of production and verification. The Zn²⁺ result was produced and verified by separate toolchains with separately sourced code. The verifier's measurements were hash-sealed before it read the producing run's claims. 3. Results I: the deposited benchmark 3.1 Every deposited state is the HF determinant [M] Scope: all 22 deposit systems with saved statevectors, 5 seeds each. All 22 reproduce the deposit hf_energy; for 7 of them this requires replicating the engine's SPIN-FIX behavior (§4). Result: max |E_sector − E_HF| = 1.3 × 10⁻⁵ Ha. The dominant determinant is the