Abstract
Volatile anesthetics reversibly suppress plant irritability — action potentials, habituation, and stimulus summation — with the same dose-dependent profile as in animal nervous tissue. This observation, documented by Jagadish Chandra Bose (1913–1926) and independently confirmed in peer-reviewed journals [Yokawa et al., 2018], lacks a mechanistic explanation: plants possess neither neurons nor synapses, the classical targets of anesthetic action. We propose the Bose–Penrose hypothesis: volatile anesthetics suppress plant irritability through the same molecular mechanism as animal anesthesia — binding to hydrophobic pockets within tubulin, disrupting quantum superpositions of tubulin conformational states as proposed by Orchestrated Objective Reduction (Orch OR; Penrose & Hameroff, 1996). Three independent lines of evidence support this claim. First, plant tubulin shares ~75% sequence homology with animal tubulin, and hydrophobic pocket geometry is evolutionarily conserved, as demonstrated by identical efficacy of colchicine, taxol, and nocodazole across plant and animal microtubules [Morejohn, 1991]. Second, the molecular mechanism of anesthetic action is specific to protein hydrophobic pockets, not lipid membranes: non-immobilizer compounds with high lipophilicity lack anesthetic activity; stereoisomers differ in potency; purified luciferase is inhibited by volatile anesthetics in the complete absence of membranes [Franks & Lieb, 1982; 1994; Koblin et al., 1994]. Third, volatile anesthetics alter collective THz oscillations of tubulin proportionally to clinical potency [Craddock et al., 2017], and the microtubule stabilizer epothilone B delays anesthetic-induced unconsciousness in rats [Pal et al., 2024]. Furthermore, Bose's five phenomena constitute a four-level memory hierarchy spanning milliseconds to weeks — temporal summation (ms), Venus flytrap two-touch rule (~30 s), fatigue (min–h), and habituation (28 days [Gagliano et al., 2014]) — implemented entirely without neurons. The Venus flytrap two-touch rule is analyzed as a distributed quorum-detection problem: spatial summation across physically separated trigger hairs without a central integrating node. These observations make plants a uniquely clean model for studying the physical substrate of biological memory, precisely because the absence of neurons eliminates competing mechanisms. Critically, plant cells offer a methodological advantage unavailable in neurons: they lack GABA-A receptors, NMDA receptors, opioid receptors, and other classical neuronal anesthetic targets. Tubulin is thus virtually the exclusive molecular candidate for anesthetic action in plant cells — making plants a cleaner model system for testing the tubulin mechanism than neurons themselves. The hypothesis implies that neurons are not the unique substrate of quantum computation, but an evolutionary specialization of a mechanism universal to all eukaryotes. We formulate six testable predictions spanning molecular, biophysical, behavioral, and optical levels of analysis: (1) affinity of volatile anesthetics for plant tubulin predicts potency of irritability suppression; (2) Arabidopsis thaliana CRISPR mutants with modified hydrophobic pockets show altered anesthetic sensitivity; (3) plant microtubules exhibit a scale-invariant resonance hierarchy analogous to that described for neural microtubules; (4) microtubule-disrupting agents impair habituation in Mimosa pudica; (5) terpenoid microtubule stabilizers enhance, rather than suppress, plant irritability; (6) volatile anesthetics alter birefringence of microtubule networks in living plant cells, detectable by polarization microscopy without fluorescent labeling. None of these experiments have been performed. Their results — in either direction — will advance understanding of the molecular basis of eukaryotic irritability and may reframe the question of where, in the continuous spectrum of living matter, quantum computation begins.